2000: shrAvaN: Atmadharma : 155 :
paranA kartRutvanA mahAahankArarUp agnAnAndhakAr evo je agnAnIno pratibhAs te
‘vyavahar’
prashna:– shAstromAn ‘vyavahAr’ shabda ghaNe ThekANe vAparavAmAn Ave chhe teno artha shun chhe?
uttar:– ‘vyavahAr’ shabdanA ghaNA artha thAy chhe; temAn ‘agnAnInI paranA kartRuttvanI khoTI mAnyatA
(pratibhAs) te vyavahAr’ evo ek artha thAy chhe.
prashna:– vyavahArano je artha karyo te barAbar samajAy te mATe visheSh spaShTa karo.
uttar:– kharekhar jIvanI pravRutti (kriyA) ane jaD padArthonI pravRutti (kriyA) bhinna–tadna judI chhe; paN
jIv sAchun gnAn pragaT na kare tyAn sudhI te sthuL draShTithI jue chhe ane tethI temanI pravRutti judI judI hovA chhatAn
ek jevI dekhAy chhe. agnAn dashAmAn jIvane jIv ane jaD padArthonun bhedagnAn [sAchun gnAn] nahi hovAthI
upalak draShTie uparachhalun jevun dekhAy tevun (UnDo vichAr karyA vagar) te mAnI le chhe, ane tethI te em mAne chhe
ke jIv jaDakarmane kare chhe ane bhogave chhe; shrIguru bhedagnAn karAvI jIvanun sAchun svarUp batAvIne agnAnInA e
pratibhAsane “vyavahAr” kahe chhe.
prashna:– agnAn dashAmAn jIv kartApaNAnA sambandhamAn shun ane kayArathI mAne chhe?
uttar:– A jagatamAn agnAn dashAmAn jIvono “paradravyane athavA tenI avasthAne hun karUn chhun.” evA
paradravyanA kartRutvanA mahA ahankArarUp agnAnAndhakAr (ke je atyant anant puruShArthathI TALI shakAy chhe te)
anAdi sansArathI chAlyo Ave chhe.
prashna:– ek vastu (jIv) par vastu (jaD) nun kAI kem na karI shake? e samajAvo.
uttar:– darek vastu potAthI potAnA vastupaNe (dravye), potAthI potAnA pradeshapaNe (kShetre–AkAre,)
potAthI potAnI avasthApaNe (kALe), ane pote potAthI potAnA guNapaNe (bhAve) chhe; ane te vastu
paravastunA dravye–kShetre–kALe ane bhAve nathI. have je ek vastu bIjI vastumAn dravye–kShetre–kALe ane bhAve nathI te
bIjAne shun karI shake? kAI ja na karI shake e spaShTa chhe.
je je vastuo chhe te te sarvathA bhinna ja chhe, pradeshabhedavALI ja chhe. bannenA kShetro bhinna ja rahe chhe. A
pramANe svakShetre darek dravya trikALI bhinna chhe tethI, tathA svadravye darek dravya trikALI bhinna chhe tethI, tathA svakALe
darek dravya trikALI bhinna chhe tethI, tathA svabhAve darek dravya trikALI bhinna chhe tethI koI dravya–koI guN ke koI
paryAy paranun kAI karI shake nahIn.
prashna:– tyAre jIv paradravyanun kAI karI shake em mAnavun te mahAahankAr chhe?
uttar:– hA, tem ja chhe. pote paranun kAI karI shakato nathI chhatAn karun chhun em mAne chhe tethI tene ‘ahankAr’
kahevAmAn Ave chhe, ane te khoTI mAnyatA anant sansAranun [dukhanun] kAraN chhe, ane tene TALavA mATe anant
puruShArthanI jarUr chhe tethI tene ‘mahA’ kahevAmAn Ave chhe.
prashna:– A mahA ahankArane agnAn andhakAr kem kahevAmAn Ave chhe?
uttar:– kAraN ke pote potAnun sAchun gnAn karyun nahIn ane mahAn bhUl karI tethI tene mahA ahankArarUp
agnAn andhakAr kahevAmAn Ave chhe.
prashna:– tyAre to em thayun ke mahA ahankArarUp agnAnAndhakArane agnAnIno pratibhAs ane te pratibhAsane
‘vyavahAr’ kahevAmAn Ave chhe em Tharyun–e kharUn?
uttar:– hA, tem ja chhe.
prashna:– A bAbatamAn je shAstrAdhAr hoy te jaNAvo!
uttar:– hA, shAstrAdhAr chhe. shrI samayasAranI gAthA 84 thI 86 tenI TIkA bhAvArtha ane kalash 51 thI
56 (pAnAn–123 thI 128 sudhI) vAnchIne vichAravAthI vastunun svarUp yathArthapaNe samajI shakAshe.
prashna:– A mahA ahankArane TALavAno upAy shun chhe?
uttar:– A mahA ahankArarUp agnAnAndhakAr te agnAnIno pratibhAs chhe, tethI tene vyavahAr kahevAmAn
Ave chhe. mATe vyavahArane jem chhe tem jANI teno Ashray chhoDavAthI ane ek dravya bIjA dravyanun kAI karI shake
nahIn em nakkI karI potAnA trikALI dhurav svabhAvano Ashray levAthI