: vaishAkh : 2477 : 153 :
vinA samyakatvanI utpatti gote to te maLashe nahIn; ne chaitanyasvarUp dhurav AtmAnA avalamban vinA paN
samyagdarshan nahi maLe.
samyaktvanI utpattinI sAthe ja AtmAnI dhuravatA ane mithyAtvano vyay hoy chhe; te bannene mAnyA vinA
samyaktvano utpAd siddha nahi thAy. mATImAn, mATIpaNAnI dhuravatA ane pinD–avasthAnA vyay vagar ghaDAnI
utpatti siddha thAy nahIn. ane jo jagatamAn ghaDArUp ek bhAvanI utpatti na thAy to jagatamAn samyaktva,
siddhadashA vagere koI bhAvonI utpatti ja nahi thAy. tem ja jo mATI vagar ja ghaDo thAy to AkAshanun phUl paN
thAy eTale ke vastunI hayAtI vagar–addharathI ja navA navA bhAvo utpanna thavA mAnDe,–AtmA vagar ja samyaktva
Upaje–e rIte moTo doSh Ave chhe. AtmAnI dhuravatAnA avalamban vagar ja kadI samyaktvanI utpatti thAy nahIn.
parathI lAbh thashe evI je mithyAruchi chhe te parasanmukh ruchinA abhAv vagar ane svadravyanI dhuravatAnA
avalamban vagar samakitanI utpatti thaI shakashe nahIn.
tem samyaggnAnanI utpatti bAbat : dhurav gnAnAnand AtmAnA avalambanathI, ane agnAnanA vyayathI
samyaggnAnanI utpatti thAy chhe. dhurav chetan vinA ane agnAnanA vyay vinA samyaggnAnanI utpatti shodhe to te
maLashe nahIn.
tem chAritranI utpatti bAbat : bahAranI kriyAmAn ke sharIranI nagna avasthAmAn AtmAnun chAritra nathI.
chAritra eTale AtmAnI vItarAgaparyAy; te vItarAgaparyAy rAganA abhAvathI ane dhurav chidAnand AtmAnA
avalambanathI Upaje chhe, mahAvrat vagerenA rAgathI te UpajatI nathI. dhuravatAnun avalamban ane rAgano abhAv–
e banne vinA vItarAgabhAvanI utpatti thaI shake nahIn.
e ja pramANe kevaLagnAnanI utpatti dhurav chaitanya–svabhAvanA avalamban vinA ane pUrvanI apUrNa gnAn–
dashAnA vyay vinA thatI nathI. AtmAnI dhuravatA rahIne ane alpagnatAno vyay thaIne pUrNagnAnanI utpatti thAy chhe.
chhellI siddha dashA,–te paN AtmAnI dhuravatA ane sansAradashAno vyay–e banne sahit ja thAy chhe.
AmAn dhuravatA te bhAvasAdhan chhe ne vyay te abhAvasAdhan chhe.
uparanA draShTAnto pramANe jagatanA jaD ke chetan badhA bhAvonA utpAdamAn samajavun. koI paN bhAvano
utpAd vastunI dhuravatA vinA ane pUrva bhAvanA vyay vinA hoto nathI.
jo mATI vagar ja ghaDA utpanna thavA mAnDe to to AkAshapuShpanI jem vastu vagar ja jagatamAn avasthAo
thavA mAnDashe. jem AkAshanAn phUl nathI tem dhuravasvabhAv vagar paryAyano utpAd thato nathI. dhurav AtmAnA
avalamban vagar samyaktvaparyAyano utpAd thAy nahi. jagatamAn jo sasalAnAn shIngaDAn thAy, kAchabAnA vAL
thAy ke AkAshanAn phUl thAy to dhuravanA avalamban vagar samyaktva thAy.–te vAt kadI bane nahi. dhuravatattva vagar
ekalA shUnyamAnthI ja koI bhAvanI utpatti thAy nahIn. mATe utpAd sAthe dhurav tem ja vyayane paN mAnavA
joIe. Avun ja utpAd–vyay–dhuravarUp vastusvarUp chhe, sarvagnadevanA gnAnamAn A ja pramANe jaNAyun chhe, temanI
vANImAn A ja rIte Avyun chhe, santoe paN e ja rIte jANIne kahyun chhe ne shAstromAn paN e ja kahyun chhe.–AvA
vastusvarUpane je nathI jANato te kharekhar dev–guru–shAstrane jANato nathI.
juo bhAI! sat saraL chhe, sahaj chhe, sugam chhe. paN agnAnatAthI viSham mAnI lIdhun chhe tethI kaThaN
lAge chhe. satsamAgame dhIro thaIne samaje to sat sahelun chhe, sahaj chhe. A vastusvabhAv samajyA vagar koI
rIte kalyAN thatun nathI.
vastu ek samayamAn utpAd–vyay–dhuravasvarUp chhe. vikAranI ruchino abhAv ane nitya AtmAnA avalamban
vagar samyaktvanI utpatti thatI nathI. vastumAn jo dhurav ane vyay na hoy to utpAd thAy nahIn. e pramANe ek
utpAdanI vAt karI, ane ekalo utpAd mAnavAmAn doSh Ave chhe te batAvyun. have vyayanI vAt kare chhe:
[2] ekalo vyay mAnavAmAn AvatA doSh
dhurav ane utpAd vagarano ekalo vyay mAnavAmAn paN doSh Ave chhe. dhurav ane utpAd vagar ekalo
vyay na hoy.
koI kahe: mATImAn pinDaparyAyano nAsh thayo paN ghaTaparyAyanI utpatti na thaI tem ja mATI kAyam na