vaLI anya paN ghaNAn kathano pramANaviruddha kahe chhe. jem kahe chhe ke – sarvArthasiddhino dev
manathI ja prashna kare chhe, ane kevalIbhagavAn manathI ja uttar Ape chhe. have sAmAnya jIvanA
ja mananI vAt manaparyay gnAnI vinA jANI shake nahi, to kevaLInA mananI vAt sarvArthasiddhino
dev kevI rIte jANe? vaLI kevalIne bhAvamanano to abhAv chhe, tathA dravyaman jaD chhe –
AkAramAtra chhe, to uttar koNe Apyo? mATe e mithyA chhe.
e pramANe anek pramANaviruddha kathan karyAn chhe, mATe temanAn Agam kalpit jANavAn.
✾ shvetAmbaramat kathit dev – guru – dhArmanun anyathA svarup ✾
shvetAmbaramatavALA dev – guru – dharmanun svarUp paN anyathA nirUpaN kare chhe.
devanun anyathA svarup —
kevaLIne kShudhAdik doSh kahe chhe, e devanun anyathA svarUp chhe. kAraN ke – kShudhAdik doSh
hotAn AkulatA hoy tyAre anant sukh kevI rIte bane? ahIn jo kahesho ke – ‘‘sharIrane kShudhA
lAge chhe, paN AtmA tadrUp thato nathI’’ to kShudhAdikano upAy, AhArAdik grahaN karyo shA
mATe kaho chho? kShudhAdivaDe pIDit thAy, tyAre ja AhAr grahaN kare. jo kahesho ke – ‘‘jem
karmodayathI vihAr thAy chhe, te ja pramANe AhAr grahaN thAy chhe.’’ paN vihAr to
vihAyogatiprakRitinA udayathI thAy chhe, tathA e pIDAno upAy nathI, ichchhA vinA paN koI
jIvane thato joIe chhIe; parantu AhAr chhe, te prakRitinA udayathI nathI, kShudhA vaDe pIDit thatAn
ja grahaN kare chhe. vaLI AtmA pavanAdikane prere tyAre ja tenun gaLI javun thAy chhe, mATe
vihAravat AhAr nathI.
jo kahesho ka — ‘‘shAtAvedanIyanA udayathI AhAr grahaN thAy chhe,’’ to e paN banatun
nathI. kAraN ke – je jIv kShudhAvaDe pIDit hoy, ane pAchhaLathI AhArAdi grahaNathI sukh mAne,
tene AhArAdik shAtAnA udayathI thayAn kahevAy. shAtAvedanIyanA udayathI AhArAdikanun grahaN
svayam thAy, em to nathI. jo em hoy to shAtAvedanIyano mukhya uday devone chhe, to teo
nirantar AhAr kem karatA nathI? vaLI mahAmuni upavAsAdik kare chhe temane shAtAno uday
paN hoy chhe, tyAre nirantar bhojan karavAvALAne ashAtAno uday paN sambhave chhe.
mATe jem ichchhAvinA paN vihAyogatinA udayathI vihAr sambhave chhe, tem ichchhA
vinA kevaL shAtAvedanIyanA ja udayathI AhAr grahaN sambhavatun nathI. tyAre te kahe chhe ke –
‘‘siddhAntamAn kevaLIne kShudhAdik agiyAr pariShah kahyA chhe, tethI tene kShudhAno sadbhAv sambhave
chhe. vaLI AhArAdik vinA tenI (kShudhAnI) upashAntatA kevI rIte thAy? mATe tene AhArAdik
mAnIe chhIe.’’
pAnchamo adhikAra anyamat nirAkaraN ][ 149