-
pA.NchavA.N adhikAr ][ 111
svargAdikako anAdinidhan mAnate hai.n. tU kahegA — jIvAdik va svargAdik kaise hue? ham kahe.nge
paramabrahma kaise huA? tU kahegA — inakI rachanA aisI kisane kI? ham kahe.nge — paramabrahmako
aisA kisane banAyA? tU kahegA — paramabrahma svaya.nsiddha hai; ham kahe.nge — jIvAdik va svargAdik
svaya.nsiddha hai.n. tU kahegA — inakI aur paramabrahmakI samAnatA kaise sambhav hai? to sambhAvanAme.n
dUShaN batalA. lokako navIn utpanna karanA, usakA nAsh karanA, usame.n to hamane anek doSh
dikhAye. lokako anAdinidhan mAnanese kyA doSh hai? so tU batalA.
yadi tU paramabrahma mAnatA hai so alag koI hai hI nahI.n; is sa.nsArame.n jIv hai.n ve
hI yathArtha j~nAnase mokShamArga sAdhanese sarvaj~na vItarAg hote hai.n.
yahA.N prashna hai ki — tum nyAre-nyAre jIv anAdinidhan kahate ho; mukta honeke pashchAt
to nirAkAr hote hai.n, vahA.N nyAre-nyAre kaise sambhav hai.n?
samAdhAn : — mukta honeke pashchAt sarvaj~nako dikhate hai.n yA nahI.n dikhate? yadi dikhate hai.n to
kuCh AkAr dikhatA hI hogA. binA AkAr dekhe kyA dekhA? aur nahI.n dikhate to yA to
vastu hI nahI.n hai yA sarvaj~na nahI.n hai. isaliye indriyaj~nAnagamya AkAr nahI.n hai us apekShA nirAkAr
hai.n aur sarvaj~na j~nAnagamya hai.n, isaliye AkAravAn hai.n. jab AkAravAn Thahare tab alag-alag
ho.n to kyA doSh lagegA? aur yadi tU jAti apekShA ek kahe to ham bhI mAnate hai.n. jaise
gehU.N bhinna-bhinna hai.n unakI jAti ek hai; — is prakAr ek mAne.n to kuCh doSh nahI.n hai.
is prakAr yathArtha shraddhAnase lokame.n sarva padArtha akR^itrim bhinna-bhinna anAdinidhan mAnanA.
yadi vR^ithA hI bhramase sach-jhUThakA nirNay na kare to tU jAne, apane shraddhAnakA phal tU pAyegA.
brahmase kulapravR^itti AdikA pratiShedh
tathA ve hI brahmase putra-pautrAdi dvArA kulapravR^itti kahate hai.n. aur kulo.nme.n rAkShas, manuShya, dev,
tirya.ncho.nke paraspar prasUti bhed batalAte hai.n. vahA.N devase manuShya va manuShyase dev va tirya.nchase manuShya
ityAdi — kisI mAtA kisI pitAse kisI putra-putrIkA utpanna honA batalAte hai.n so kaise sambhav hai?
tathA manahIse va pavanAdise va vIrya sU.Nghane Adise prasUtikA honA batalAte hai.n so
pratyakShaviruddha bhAsit hotA hai. aisA honese putra-pautrAdikakA niyam kaise rahA? tathA ba.De-ba.De
mahanto.nko anya-anya mAtA-pitAse huA kahate hai.n; so mahanta puruSh kushIlavAn mAtA-pitAke kaise
utpanna ho.nge? yah to lokame.n gAlI hai. phi ra aisA kahakar unako maha.ntatA kisaliye kahate hai.n?
tathA gaNeshAdikakI mail Adise utpatti batalAte hai.n va kisIke a.ng kisIme.n ju.De
batalAte hai.n. ityAdi anek pratyakShaviruddha kahate hai.n.