326 ] [ pravachan ratnAkar bhAg-8 lakSha kare chhe te ene vikAranun-rAgAdinun kAraN chhe. potAnun svarUp chhe eno sva-svAmI sambandh na karatAn je svarUpamAn nathI evA paradravyo ne puNya-pApanA bhAvomAn svAmitvanI pratIti kare chhe tethI ene rAg thAy chhe ne bandhan thAy chhe; emAn paradravya nimitta kAraN chhe. nimitta kAraN chhe eTale em nahi ke paradravya ene nimittakAraN thaIne rAg karAve chhe, paN pote paradravyanA lakShe pariName chhe tethI rAg thAy chhe em artha chhe. samajANun kAI...?

ahin kahe chhe-AtmA svabhAvathI rAgAdino akArak ja chhe. have tenun kAraN Ape chhe ke jo em na hoy arthAt jo AtmA potAthI ja rAgAdibhAvono kArak hoy to apratikramaN ane apratyAkhyAnanA dvividhapaNAno upadesh banI shake nahi. shun kIdhun? ke AtmA svabhAvathI ja jo shubhAshubh bhAvono kartA hoy to bhagavAne, dravya-bhAvanun pratikramaN kar, dravya-bhAvanun pratyAkhyAn kar-em je be prakAre (dravyabhAvano) upadesh karyo chhe te banI shake nahi. dravya eTale sanyogI chIj ne bhAv eTale shubhAshubh vikAr-em beyathI pAchhA pharavAno ne beyanA pachakhANano je bhagavAnano upadesh chhe te banI shake nahi kemake AtmA svabhAvathI ja rAgAdino kArak hoy to te rAgAdithI kevI rIte pAchho phare? enun pachakhAN kevI rIte kare?

kharekhar to beyathI (dravya ne bhAvathI) pAchhun haTavun-evo bhagavAnano upadesh chhe. paN rAgAdino jo AtmA kharekhar kartA hoy to enAthI pAchhun haThavun hoI shake nahi. A nyAyano jarI jhINo viShay chhe.

pahelAn kahyun ke AtmA trikALI dhruv ekalo chaitanyabimb prabhu rAgadveShAdi vikAranA bhAvono potAnA svabhAvathI akArak ja chhe. have kahe chhe-jo em na hoy to, bhagavAnanA upadeshamAn je em Avyun ke-bhAv eTale shubhAshubh vikAr ane dravya eTale e vikAranun nimitta bAhyachIj-e beyathI pAchho haTh-e banI shake nahi. vikAr jo enun svarUp ja hoy to enAthI pAchhA haThavAnun kem banI shake?

shun kIdhun? AmAn nyAy samajAy chhe? je sanyogI chIj vikAramAn nimitta chhe tene dravya kahIe ane paryAyamAn je vikAr chhe tene bhAv kahIe. have bhagavAne upadeshamAn em kahyun ke dravya-bhAv beyathI khasI jA, arthAt vikAranun nimitta je bAhyachIj enAthI khasI jA ne vikArathIy haThI jA. parantu AtmA jo svabhAvathI ja vikArano ne nimittano kartA hoy to ‘enAthI, pAchho haThI jA’ -em upadesh hoI shake nahi. mATe em nakkI thayun ke vikAr ne vikAranA nimittanun karavApaNun svabhAvathI AtmAne chhe ja nahi arthAt AtmA akArak ja chhe; ane tethI ja dravya-bhAv-beyathI pAchho haThI jA em bhagavAnano upadesh chhe. samajANun kAI...?