16] [pravachan ratnAkar bhAg-9 astipaNAno niShedh nathI, paN te upAdAnanI paryAyanun kaIpaN kare nahi.

tem vyavahAr chhe te nishchayanun kAI kare nahi. kemake vyavahAr chhe te paN nimitta chhe. vyavahAr chhe kharo, paN vyavahAr nishchayanun kAI kare nahi.

pAnchamo A kramabaddhano viShay; pratyek dravyanI sarva paryAyo tenA thavAnA kALe svatantrapaNe potAthI ja kramabaddha thAy chhe. temAn kAI Aghun-pAchhun kadIy thAy nahi.

have ek chhaThThI vAta bahAr em vAt AvI chhe ke-paryAy ashuddha hoy to dravya paN ashuddha thaI jAy.

parantu A mAnyatA yathArtha nathI. vastu je dravya chhe e to anAdi anant ekarUp pavitratAno pinD chhe. vikArI-nirvikArI sarva paryAyonA kALe dravya to shAshvat ekarUp shuddha chhe. are! tIvra mithyAtvanA kALe paN dravya-vastu to jevI chhe tevI shuddha ja chhe.

prashna– to shuddha-ashuddha dravya em kahe chhe ne?

samAdhAna– hA, paN e to paryAy-apekShAe vAt chhe. shuddhatA ne ashuddhatA e to paryAyanI vAt chhe bhAI! vastu-dravya to trikAL ekarUp shuddha ja chhe. are! pote koN chhe? kevo chhe? kevaDo chhe? enI potAne kAI khabar na maLe ane badhI paranI mAnDI chhe. kahevat chhe ne ke- ‘gharanAn chhokarAn ghanTI chATe ne pADoshIne ATo’ -em A paN potAnI khabar kare nahi ane bahAramAn DahApaN DahoLe-jANe devano dIkaro; paN bhAI! svane jANyA vinA e badhun tArun DahApaN to narI mUDhatA chhe, pAgalapaNun chhe-bApu!

bhAI! tun sAmbhaL to kharo ke ahIn A shun kahe chhe! ahAhA....! kahe chhe-pratham to jIv kramabaddha evA potAnA pariNAmothI upajato thako jIv ja chhe, ajIv nathI. juo, trikALI shuddha jIv-vastu chhe e to dhruv apariNAmI chhe; temAn badalavun (kriyA) nathI. paN vartamAn paryAy chhe te enI badalatI dashA chhe. ahIn kahe chhe-te vartamAn-vartamAn badalatI dashA chhe te kramabaddha chhe. mUL pAThamAn ‘kramaniyamit’ shabda chhe, teno ahIn ‘kramabaddha’ artha karyo chhe. matalab ke jIvanI anAdi anant traNakALanI je paryAyo chhe te pratyek potAnA svakALe kramaniyamit-kramabaddha pragaT thAy chhe. vaLI jIvanI te pratyek badalatI-upajatI dashA-paryAy jIv ja chhe, ajIv nathI. eTale shun? ke te te upajatA pariNAmomAn jIv ja tanmay chhe, paN emAn