koI vaLI kahe chhe-kramabaddhano artha ek pachhI ek thAy em barAbar, paN amuk A ja thAy em nahi. parantu evI vastusthiti nathI bhAI! dravyanI (trikALavartI) pratyek paryAyano kram niyat-nishchit ja chhe. koI paryAy kadIy ADIavaLI thaI shake nahi. darek paryAy potAnA kShaNik upAdAnanI yogyatAnusAr je kALe je thavAyogya hoy te ja te kALe nishchit pragaT thAy chhe.
juo, AtmAmAn ek vibhutvashakti chhe enI ahIn vAt chhe. A vibhutvashakti pUrA dravyamAn ane tenA anant guNomAn vyApak chhe. dravyanI anant shaktio kramabaddha paryAyapaNe pariName chhe. bahidraShTine teno andar svIkAr thato nathI, paN ek abhed shuddha antatattvanI draShTi karatAn ja paryAy kramabaddha thAy chhe teno yathArtha nirNay thAy chhe. ame to A vAt pravachanomAn vistArathI karI chhe
prashna– to Ap chhApIne bahAr pADavAnun kaho to vahelI prasiddha thAy. uttara– ame koIne kAI kahetA nathI. tattva-vichAr ane svAdhyAy karavA sivAy bIjA koI kAmamAn ame paDatA nathI. shun chhApavun ne bahAr pADavun e samAjanun kAm chhe, amArun te kAm nathI.
A vibhutva nAmanI shakti sarva shaktiomAn vyApe chhe, dravya-guN-paryAy traNemAn vyApe chhe. tethI dravya vibhu, guN vibhu ne vartamAn paryAy vibhu chhe. sUkShma vAt chhe prabhu! A gnAnasvabhAv vibhu chhe, ne gnAnanI vartamAn dashA vibhu chhe. gnAnanI kramasar paryAy sunishchit je thavAyogya hoy te ja pragaT thAy chhe, ane tenI sAthe anant guNanI paN te samaye sunishchit je paryAy pragaT thavAnI hoy te ja pragaT thAy chhe, anant guNanI paryAyamAn paN A vibhutva guN vyApe chhe.
tyAre koI vaLI kahe chhe-kramabaddha paryAy mAnavAthI niyat (-niyatavAd) thaI jAy chhe. are bhAI! jem dravya ane tenI shakti niyat chhe ane nishchit chhe tem potAnI kShaNik upAdAnanI yogyatA anusAr samay samaye pragaT thatI darek paryAy paN niyat ja chhe. je samaye je paryAy thavAyogya chhe te ja pragaT thAy chhe; paN paryAy kramabaddha chhe evo nirNay karanAranI draShTi trikALI shuddha ek gnAyak upar jAy chhe tyAre ja kramabaddhano yathArtha nirNay thAy chhe. dravyadraShTi rahit agnAnIne A vAt goThatI nathI. te kahe chhe-shrutagnAnanI apekShA niyat nathI. paN bhAI! tAro tarka yathArtha nathI, kemake shrutagnAnanI apekShA paN darek paryAy kramabaddha ja chhe evo yathArtha nirNay samyagdraShTine hoy chhe. bhAI! jarA draShTi sUkShma karI A samajavA mATe prayatna karavo joIe; A avasar chhe.
prashna– hA, paN panchAstikAyanI gAthA 1papamAn sansArI jIvane niyat tathA aniyat em banne prakAranI paryAyo thayA kare chhe em kahyun chhe ne? gAthA A pramANe chhe-
uttara– hA, panchAstikAyanI gAthA 1papamAn niyat ane aniyat paryAyanI vAt chhe. tyAn svabhAv ane svabhAvalIn nirmaL paryAy pragaT thAy tene niyat kahel chhe ane vibhAv paryAy pragaT thAy tene aniyat kahel chhe. aniyat paryAy eTale te AgaL-pAchhaL ke ADI-avaLI thAy evo tyAn artha nathI. aniyat eTale svabhAvamAn anavasthit anekarUp vikArI paryAy; te paN je samaye pragaT thAy te niyat kramabaddha ja pragaT thAy chhe. gAthAmAn ane TIkAmAn paN guN-svabhAv ane nirmaL paryAyane niyat kahel chhe, ane vikArI vibhAv paryAyane aniyat kahel chhe. ahIn aniyatano artha paryAy ADI-avaLI thAy chhe em chhe nahi. bhAI! potAnI mati-kalpanAthI shAstranA artha kare te kem chAle? na chAle. pANIno shItaL svabhAv te niyat chhe, svabhAvalIn shItaL dashA te niyat chhe ane agninA nimitte tenI uShNa dashA te aniyat chhe. AvI vAt! samajANun kAI...!
shun thAy? lokone pUrvanA Agrah (haThAgrah) hoy eTale A bese nahi. A vAt pahelAn hatI nahi; hamaNAn sonagaDhathI prasiddhimAn AvI chhe eTale keTalAk haThapUrvak teno virodh kare chhe. e to ‘jainatattvamImAnsA’mAn kevaLagnAn- svabhAvamImAnsA nAmanA prakaraNamAn pt.. shrI. phUlachandajIe A bAbate kahyun chhe ke-“jyArathI sarva dravyonI paryAyo kramaniyamit (kramabaddha) thAy chhe A tathya pramukharUpathI badhAnI sAme Avyun chhe tyArathI vidvAno dvArA AvA kutarka uThAvavAmAn AvyA chhe. jemanA manamAn evun shalya ghar karI beThun chhe ke kevaLagnAnane sarva dravyo ane tenI sarva paryAyonun gnAtA mAnI