: phAgaN : 2011 : Atmadharma–137 : 131 :
‘nay’nA svarUp sambandhI spaShTatA
* nay te jaD nathI paN shrutagnAno ansh chhe *
lekhAnk pahelo
* * * * * *
hamaNAn hamaNAn jainapatronA keTalAk lekhomAn “nay”nA svarUpasambandhI ghaNI viparIt prarUpaNA chAlI rahI
chhe; tethI “nay”nA svarUp sambandhamAn ahIn keTalIk spaShTatA karavAmAn AvI chhe, ane te sambandhI shAstrAdhAro
ApavAmAn AvyA chhe. [pU. gurudevanI preraNAthI A lekh taiyAr thayo chhe.]
A lekhanI bhUmikA
(1) “nay te jaD nathI paN shrutagnAnano ansh chhe” e A lekhano mukhya viShay chhe. bhagavAn shrI
kundakundAdi AchAryabhagavantoe samayasArAdi tathA ShaTkhanDAgamAdi shAstromAn spaShTapaNe e siddhAntanun pratipAdan karyun
chhe ke “nishchayanayanA Ashraye ja mukti thAy chhe, ne vyavahAranayanA avalambanathI mokSha thato nathI,” ane e
rahasyane Aje pU. gurudev suprasiddha karIne samajAvI rahyA chhe. keTalAk jIvone A vAt IShTa nathI lAgatI tethI,
‘nishchayanayanA Ashraye mukti thAy’ e vAtano virodh karavA mATe teo em kahe chhe ke ‘nishchayanay te gnAn
nathI paN jaD chhe. ’ gnAnanA anshane jaD kahenArun temanun A kathan AgamothI ekadam viparIt chhe. vAstavikapaNe
‘nay’ te jaD nathI paN shrutagnAnano ansh chhe evun darshAvanArA keTalAk mukhya shAstra AdhAro ahIn ApavAmAn
AvyA chhe.
(2) koI em kahe ke “nay shabdAtmak ja chhe, ane nayane gnAn kahevun te upachAr chhe” to te vAt satya
nathI parantu viparIt chhe; kemake ‘nay’ te vAstavikapaNe gnAn ja chhe ane shabdane nay kahevo te upachArathI chhe;
nayane gnAnAtmak kahevo te upachAr nathI paN nayane shabdAtmak kahevo te upachAr chhe. A sabandhamAn paN
keTalAk mukhya shAstrAdhAro ahIn ApavAmAn AvyA chhe.
(3) shAstramAn ghaNIvAr nay ane nayanA viShayanun abhedapaNe kathan karavAmAn Ave chhe,– ane tevA
prasangamAn nayanA viShayabhUt padArthane paN nay kahevAmAn Ave chhe. te sambandhI paN keTalAk shAstrAdhAro ApavAmAn
AvyA chhe.
(4) shAstramAn anek sthaLoe nayane tenA viShayabhUt padArthano “grAhak” kahevAmAn Ave chhe, tyAn
“grAhak”no artha “jANanAr” thAy chhe. jem “pramAN” potAnA viShayanun grAhak eTale ke jANanAr chhe tem
‘nay’ paN potAnA viShayano grAhak eTale ke jANanAr chhe. temAn taphAvat mAtra eTalo chhe ke pramAN potAnA
viShayabhUt padArthanun sarvadesh–grAhak chhe, jyAre nay tenA ekadeshane grAhak chhe. e rIte padArthane ane nayane
viShay–viShayIpaNun chhe. jyAn nayane ‘grAhak’ kahyo hoy tyAn grAhak eTale jANanAr evo artha thAy chhe. A
bAbatamAn paN keTalAk mukhya shAstrAdhAro ApavAmAn AvyA chhe.