bhinna hai, yah vibhAv bhinna hai. gnAnane svayamne buddhise jo nakkI kiyA hai, vah nakkI kiyA hai usakA abhyAs karatA hai. dhAraNAgnAn, bahut log shAstra dhokh lete hain, aisA dhAraNAgnAn kAm nahIn AtA. bIchamen use jAnapanA hai utanA use kuchh nimitta bane, bAkI (koI kAryakArI nahIn hai).
parantu yah jo svayam abhyAsapUrvak karatA hai, vah use vAstavik sAdhan to nahIn hai. vAstavik sAdhan to usakA jo svabhAv hai vahI use sAdhan hotA hai. parantu vah bIchamen AtA hai. use vyavahArase sAdhan kahanemen AtA hai. vyavahAr sAdhana. vyavahAr sAdhan na kahe to phir... pahalese to vah antaramen jA nahIn sakatA hai, isaliye mumukShuko kyA karanA rahatA hai? yathArtha ruchi aur main chaitanya hUn, aisI bhAvanA kare vah to bIchamen Aye binA nahIn rahatA.
mumukShu- Aye binA rahatA nahIn, vah bAt to barAbar hai lekin use sAdhan mAnane jAy to ...
samAdhAna- nahIn, vAstavik sAdhan hai aisA nahIn. mUl sAdhan to dravya svabhAvamense puruShArtha uThakar, antaramense jo uThe vah vAstavik sAdhan hotA hai. parantu vah bIchamen AtA hai, vyavahAr sAdhan kahanemen AtA hai.
jaise anAdi kAlase gurukA upadesh aur jinendrakA upadesh use nimittarUpase deshanAlabdhi hotI hai, to vah bhI use ek sAdhan nimittarUpase kahanemen AtA hai. upAdAn hotA hai apanese, parantu anAdi kAlase aisA sambandha hai ki bIchamen gurukA upadesh aur jinendrakA upadesh, anAdi kAlakA anabhyAsI (jIv hai), jise kuchh pragaT nahIn huA, use ek bAr aisI deshanA milatI hai, andarase deshanA labdhi grahaN hotI hai svayamse, upAdAn svayamkA hai parantu usamen nimitta jinendra dev aur gurukA banatA hai, aisA nimitta-naimittik sambandha hai. vaise jo svayam ruchi karatA hai, mAtra dhAraNAgnAn (karatA hai), use ruchi hI nahIn hai, aisA dhAraNAgnAn dhokh liyA hai, vah nahIn. parantu vah buddhise nakkI karatA hai ki main yah gnAn hUn, darshan hUn, chAritra hUn aise jo bhedake vikalpa Ate hain, vah vikalpa to bIchamen Aye binA nahIn rahate. parantu vah vikalpa use vAstavik sAdhan hotA hai yA bhed use vAstavikarUpase sAdhan hotA hai, aisA nahIn hai.
sAdhan to apanI pariNati jo antaramense uchhalatI hai vahI usakA sAdhan hai. parantu vah bIchamen AtA hai. vah bIchamen Aye binA nahIn rahatA. jaise nimitta-upAdAnakA sambandha guru evan svayamkI deshanAlabdhikA hai, vaise hI yah gnAn hUn, darshan hUn, chAritra hUn, sAdhanAmen aise bhedavikalpa Aye binA nahIn rahate.
jo svAnubhUti kare use jo dravya par dRuShTi hai, use bhI aise bhed vikalpa bIchamen