182 pratApase sunane (milA).
mumukShu- gurudev koI bAr aisA kahate the ki paryAy jitanA hI tU nahIn hai aur koI bAr aisA kahate the ki paryAyase tU bhinna hai.
samAdhAna- paryAy jitanA tU nahIn hai arthAt paryAy to kShaN-kShaNamen badal jAtI hai. tU shAshvat AtmA hai. paryAyase bhinna arthAt paryAyakA svabhAv bhinna aur terA svabhAv bhinna hai. vah kShaNik hai, tU trikAl hai. bhinnatAkA artha aisA lenA hai, sarvathA prakArase bhinna hai aisA artha nahIn hai. apekShAse bhinna hai. sarvathA prakArase sarva prakArase bhed ho to dravya paryAy binAkA ho jAy aur paryAy svayam dravya ban jAya. is tarah sarvathA prakArase bhinnakA artha nahIn thA. parantu tU koI apekShAse bhinna hai.
tU samajh ki terA svabhAv trikAl shAshvat rahanekA hai aur paryAy kShaNik hai. aise samajhanA. us apekShAse bhinna hai. sarvathA bhinna (ho to) dravya paryAy binAkA ho jAya. to dravya use kahate hain ki jis dravyake andar utpAd-vyay-dhrauvya sahit ho vah dravva kahanemen AtA hai. aur paryAy use kahate hain ki dravyake Ashrayase jo paryAy hotI ho vah paryAy hai. paryAy vaisI svatantra nahIn hai ki vah paryAy svayam binA dravyake pariNamatI ho. aise paryAy nahIn rahatI hai. parantu dononke svabhAv bhinna hain. us apekShAse use bhinna kahanemen AtA hai. isaliye bhinna kahA hai.
mumukShu- ..
samAdhAna- hAn, paryAy jitanA nahIn hai. arthAt paryAy kShaNik hai aur tU trikAl hai.
mumukShu- mithyAtva chalA AtA ho, ek bAr to gnAnIkI deshanA niyamase jIvako prApta honI hI chAhiye.
samAdhAna- aisA nimitta-naimittik sambandha hai. anAdikA jo mithyAtva hai, usamen ek bAr sachche guru athavA sachche dev use mile to upAdAn svayamkA, parantu vANIkA nimitta banatA hai. anAdi kAlakA anajAnA mArga hai. aisI deshanA ek bAr use mile, parantu vah mAtra deshanArUpase deshanA nahIn, parantu use antaramense grahaN ho jAya. vah deshanA to sabako lAbhakartA hI hotI hai. vah to prabal nimitta hotI hai. parantu svayam andarase grahaN kare tab deshanAlabdhi ho. anAdimen ek bAr to use deshanA mile phir use sanskAr Dale to apaneAp apane upAdAnase taiyAr ho jAy, parantu ek bAr to use aisA nimitta banatA hai.
mumukShu- heyabuddhikA artha kyA hai?
samAdhAna- shubhabhAv AdaraNIy nahIn hai, shubhabhAv merA svabhAv nahIn hai. shubhabhAv