222
mumukShu- kaShAyakI kAlimA hai, gnAnamen nahIn hai. gnAnamen kAlimA nahIn hai?
samAdhAna- gnAnamen kAlimA nahIn hai, vibhAvakI jo pariNati rAg-dveShavAlI hotI hai, vaisI rAg-dveShakI pariNati gnAnamen nahIn hai. gnAnamen jAnanekA doSh hotA hai. gnAnamen jAnanekA doSh hai. jo svarUp ho usase anyathA jAne, viparItapane jAne. shraddhAke kAraN gnAnamen doSh AtA hai. shraddhA alag hai aur gnAn bhI alag hai. use mithyAgnAn kahate hain.
mumukShu- chAritraguN jaise viparItapane pariNamatA hai,...
samAdhAna- viparItapane pariName aisA viparIt nahIn hai. parantu use shraddhAkI viparItatA hai. jAnanemen viparItatA hai. kaShAyakI kAlimA hai aisA nahIn hai. isaliye viparIt-viparItamen pharka hai. isakI viparItatA jAnanekI hai aur usamen rAgakI pariNatikI hai. kaShAyakI kAlimA malin hai aur us jAtakA malin gnAnako kahanemen Aye, jAnanekI apekShA- se. dononkI pariNati alag hai. rAgakI pariNati alag aur shraddhA aur gnAnakI pariNati alag prakAr-se kAm karatI hai. hai vah bhI viparIt hai. shraddhA mithyA hai isaliye gnAn bhI mithyA hai.
mumukShu- Apane aisA kahA thA ki AtmAko nahIn jAnatA hai, vah usakA- gnAnakA doSh hai. parantu jaise chAritramen kaShAyakI kAlimA hai, vaisI kAlimA isamen nahIn hai.
samAdhAna- jAnanekA doSh hai. vaisI kAlimA nahIn hai, jAnanekA doSh hai. muumukShu- .. gnAn hai vah bhI ek prakAr-se svabhAvakA ansh kahalAtA hai na? samAdhAna- svabhAvakA ansh arthAt indriyagnAn svako nahIn jAnatA hai isaliye par taraph jAtA hai, parantu vah svabhAv chhoDakar kahIn bAhar to jAtA nahIn. vah to mAnatA hai ki main bAhar chalA gayA. svabhAv chhoDakar kahIn bAhar nahIn jAtA hai. parantu mAnyatA aisI hai ki mAnon apanA gnAn bAhar chalA jAtA hai aur bAhar-se gnAn AtA hai, aisA mAnatA hai. svabhAvako chhoDakar to kahIn nahIn jAtA.
... paDe hI hain. bhale nigodamen ho. svabhAvakA ansh to hai, usakA kahIn nAsh nahIn hotA. svabhAvakA ansh ho, vah gnAnapane svayam jAnatA hai kahAn? mAnon bAhar- se gnAn AtA hai aur mAnon main bAhar jAtA hUn. mAnyatA jUThI hai.