mumukShu- nimittakAraN aise pariNAmakA sachchA kAraN nahIn hai, vah to samajhamen AtA hai. lekin jIvadravyako upAdAnakAraNake rUpase grahaN kare to jIv nitya honese nitya rAg-dveSh hotA rahai. aur aise rAg-dveSh pariNAmakA kAraN jIv bhI nahIn ho to, to phir usakA kAraN kahAn khojanA?
samAdhAna- yah prashna to bahut chalatA hI hai. nimitta aur upAdAna. upAdAnamen to AtmA hai, lekin usakI paryAyamen vah hote hain, mUl dravyamen nahIn hote. usakI paryAyamen hote hain aur paryAy tak vibhAv simit hai. nimitta bhI hai aur upAdAn svayamkA hai. lekin mUl dravyamen usake svabhAvarUp nahIn hai, vibhAvarUp hai. vibhAvarUp hai isaliye palaT jAtA hai. vah to paryAyamen hai aur paryAy to palaT jAtI hai.
anAdikA hai, lekin vah svayam akAraN pAriNAmik dravya hai. usakI pariNatimen vah svayam nimittakI or dRuShTi detA hai isaliye hote hain. paryAyamen hote hain. svayam dravyakI or dRuShTi kare to palaT jAtA hai. vah nitya nahIn rahate. anAdise lekin vah svata svayam akAraN pAriNAmik (rUpase) pariNamate hain. nimitta hai, nimitta hai hI nahIn aisA nahIn hai. upAdAn svayamkA hai. upAdAn hai, lekin apane dravyamen vah mUl svabhAv nahIn hai. paryAyamen hote hain. paryAy palaT jAtI hai.
mumukShu- upAdAn kAraN to usakA svayamkA AtmA hI hai.
samAdhAna- hAn, vah svayam hI upAdAn kAraN hai. lekin vah paryAyamen hote hain, usake svabhAvamen nahIn hai.
mumukShu- svabhAv nahIn honese svabhAvakA Ashray lenepar usakA abhAv ho jAtA hai.
samAdhAna- palaT jAte hain. .. nimitta kuchh karatA hai, aise sab prashna Ate the, aisA koI kahatA thA, tab gurudev kahate the ki vah to akAraN pAriNAmik dravya hai. nimitta binA nahIn hotA ho to apanA svabhAv ho jAye. svabhAv nahIn hai, lekin vah apanI pariNati hai. vibhAvarUp pariNamatA hai. aur svabhAvarUp bhI svayam pariNamatA hai, dravya par dRuShTi kare to. vah apanA