AThamo adhikAr ][ 307
tIrthankaranI sAthe mokSha gayA batAvyA tyAn em jANavun ke – ek ja kALamAn eTalA muni mokSha
gayA nathI paN jyAn tIrthankar gamanAdi kriyA maTI sthir thayA tyAn temanI sAthe ATalA muni
beThA ane mokSha to AgaLapAchhaL gayA. e pramANe prathamAnuyog ane karaNAnuyoganA kathanono
virodh dUr thAy chhe. vaLI devadevAnganA sAthe UpajI, pAchhaLathI devAnganAe te sharIr tajI
vachamAn anya sharIr dharyAn; tenun prayojan na jANI kathan na karyun ane pAchhaLathI teo sAthe
sAthe manuShyaparyAyamAn UpajyAn. e pramANe vidhi meLavatAn virodh dUr thAy chhe. e ja pramANe
anya ThekANe vidhi meLavI levI.
prashna — evAn kathanomAn koI prakAre vidhi maLe chhe parantu anya virodh paN
tyAn jovAmAn Ave chhe. jem ke – neminAth svAmIno janma koI ThekANe saurIpurImAn tathA
koI ThekANe dvArAvatimAn kahyo, rAmachandrAdikanI kathA judA – judA prakArathI lakhI tathA
ekendriyAdine koI ThekANe sAsAdanaguNasthAn hovun lakhyun ane koI ThekANe na lakhyun,
ityAdi. have e kathanonI vidhi kevI rIte maLe?
uttara — evAn virodhasahit kathano kALadoShathI thayAn chhe. A kALamAn pratyakShagnAnanI
vA bahushruti puruShono to abhAv thayo ane alpabuddhi granth karavAnA adhikArI thayA, temane
bhramathI koI artha anyathA bhAse to tene kevI rIte lakhe, athavA A kALamAn jainamatamAn paN
keTalAk kaShAyI thayA chhe temaNe koI kAraN pAmIne anyathA kathan lakhyAn chhe, e pramANe anyathA
kathan thayAn tethI jainashAstromAn paN virodh bhAsavA lAgyo.
have jyAn virodh bhAse tyAn ATalun karavun ke – A kathan karavAvALA ghaNA prAmANik
chhe ke A kathan karavAvALA ghaNA prAmANik chhe? evo vichAr karI mahAn AchAryAdikonAn
kahelAn kathanane pramAN karavAn, vaLI jinamatanAn ghaNAn shAstro chhe tenI AmnAy meLavavI ane
jo paramparA AmnAyathI maLe to te kathan pramAN karavAn. eTalo vichAr karavA chhatAn paN satya –
asatyano nirNay na thaI shake to ‘jem kevaLIne bhAsyun tem pramAN chhe’ em mAnI levun.
kAraN ke – devAdikano vA tattvono nirdhAr thayA vinA to mokShamArga thAy nahi, teno to nirdhAr
paN thaI shake chhe, jo koI tenun svarUp viruddharUp kahe to potAne ja te bhAsI jAy chhe.
paN anya kathanano nirdhAr na thAy, sanshayAdi rahe vA anyathA paN jANapaNun thaI jAy, ane
jo, ‘kevaLInun kahyun pramAN chhe’ evun shraddhAn rahe to tethI mokShamArgamAn vighna nathI, em samajavun.
shankA — jem jinamatamAn nAnA prakAranAn kathan kahyAn tem anyamatamAn paN
kathan hoy chhe, have tamArA matanAn kathanane to tame je – te prakArathI sthApan karyAn ane
anya matanAn evAn kathanane tame doSh lagAvo chho e tamane rAg – dveSh chhe.
samAdhAna — kathan to nAnAprakAranAn hoy paN jo te ek ja prayojanane poShatAn