308 ][ mokShamArgaprakAshak
hoy to kAI doSh nathI, parantu jo koI ThekANe koI prayojan tathA koI ThekANe koI
prayojan poShe to tyAn doSh ja chhe. have jinamatamAn to rAgAdik maTADavAnun ek prayojan
chhe tethI temAn koI ThekANe sarvarAgAdi chhoDAvI alparAgAdi karAvavAnun prayojan poShyun chhe
tathA koI ThekANe sarvarAgAdi chhoDAvavAnun prayojan poShyun chhe, parantu rAgAdi vadhAravAnun prayojan
koI paN ThekANe nathI mATe jinamatanAn sarva kathan nirdoSh chhe. tathA anyamatamAn koI ThekANe
rAgAdi maTADavAnA prayojanasahit kathan kare chhe tyAre koI ThekANe rAgAdi vadhAravAnA
prayojanasahit kathan kare chhe, e ja pramANe anya paN prayojananI viruddhatApUrvak kathan kare chhe,
tethI anyamatanAn kathan sadoSh chhe. lokamAn paN ek ja prayojanane poShatAn judAn judAn vachan
kahe tene prAmANik kahIe chhIe, paN je anya anya prayojan poShatI vAt kare tene mUrkha
kahIe chhIe.
bIjun, jinamatamAn nAnAprakAranAn kathan kare chhe te judI judI apekShAsahit chhe, tyAn
doSh nathI paN anyamatamAn ek ja apekShApUrvak anya anya kathan kare chhe tyAn doSh chhe. jem
ke – ‘jinadevane vItarAgabhAv chhe tathA samavasaraNAdi vibhUti paN hoy chhe’ tyAn virodh nathI;
kAraN ke – samavasaraNAdi vibhUtinI rachanA indrAdik kare chhe ane tIrthankarane temAn rAgAdik nathI
tethI e banne vAto to sambhave chhe, paN anyamatamAn Ishvarane sAkShIbhUt – vItarAg paN kahe chhe
tathA tenA ja vaDe karelA kAm – krodhAdibhAv nirUpaN kare chhe; have ek AtmAne vItarAgapaNun
tathA kAm – krodhAdibhAv kem sambhave? e ja pramANe anya paN samajavun.
kALadoShathI jinamatamAn ek ja prakAre koI kathan viruddha lakhyAn chhe te to tuchchha-
buddhivAnonI bhUl chhe, kAI matamAn doSh nathI. tyAn paN jinamatano eTalo to atishay chhe
ke – pramANaviruddha kathan koI karI shake nahi. shrI neminAthasvAmIno janma koI ThekANe saurIpuramAn
tathA koI ThekANe dvArAvatImAn lakhyo chhe te game tyAn thayo hoy paN nagaramAn janma hovo
pramANaviruddha nathI, Aj paN thato dekhAy chhe. bIjun —
anyamatamAn sarvagnAdi yathArtha gnAnInA karelA granth batAve chhe, temAn paraspar viruddhatA
bhAse chhe. tyAn koI ThekANe to bALabrahmachArInI prashansA kare chhe tyAre koI ThekANe kahe chhe ke
‘putra vinA gati thAy nahi.’ have e banne viruddha kathan sAchAn kem hoy? evAn kathan tyAn
ghaNAn jovAmAn Ave chhe. vaLI pramAN viruddha kathan paN temAn hoy chhe. jem ke — ‘mukhamAn vIrya
paDavAthI mAchhalIne putra thayo.’ have A kALamAn paN em thatun koIne dekhAtun nathI ane
anumAnathI paN e maLatun nathI; evAn kathan paN temAn ghaNAn jovAmAn Ave chhe. ahIn kadAchit
sarvagnAdikanI bhUl mAnIe paN te kem bhUle? ane viruddha kathan mAnavAmAn paN Ave nahi,
mATe temanA matamAn doSh TharAvIe chhIe. em jANI ek jinamatano ja upadesh grahaN karavA
yogya chhe.