-
pA.NchavA.N adhikAr ][ 145
shvetAmbaramat vichAr
tathA kAladoShase kaShAyI jIvo.n dvArA jinamatame.n kalpit rachanA kI hai. so batalAte hai.nH —
shvetAmbar matavAle kisIne sUtra banAye unhe.n gaNadharake banAye kahate hai.n. so unase pUChate
hai.n — gaNadharane AchArA.ngAdik banAye hai.n so tumhAre varttamAname.n pAye jAte hai.n, itane pramANasahit banAye
the yA bahut pramANasahit banAye the? yadi itane pramANasahit hI banAye the to tumhAre shAstro.nme.n
AchArA.ngAdikake pado.nkA pramAN aThArah hajAr Adi kahA hai, so unakI vidhi milA do.
padakA pramAN kyA? yadi vibhaktike antako pad kahoge to kahe hue pramANase bahut pad
ho jAye.nge, aur yadi pramAN pad kahoge to us padake sAdhik (ki.nchit adhik) ikyAvan karo.D.h.h
shlok hai.n. so yah to bahut ChoTe shAstra hai.n, isalie banatA nahI.n hai. tathA AchArA.ngAdikase
dashavaikAlikAdikA pramAN kam kahA hai, aur tumhAre adhik hai, so kis prakAr banatA hai?
phi ra kahoge — ‘‘AchArA.ngAdik ba.De the; kAladoSh jAnakar unhIme.nse kitane hI sUtra
nikAlakar yah shAstra banAye hai.n.’’ tab pratham to TUTak grantha pramAN nahI.n hai. tathA aisA niyam
hai ki — ba.DA grantha banAye to usame.n sarva varNan vistArasahit karate hai.n aur ChoTA grantha banAye
to yahA.N sa.nkShipta varNan karate hai.n, parantu sambandha TUTatA nahI.n hai aur kisI ba.De granthame.nse tho.DAsA
kathan nikAl le.n to vahA.N sambandha nahI.n milegA — kathanakA anukram TUT jAyagA. parantu tumhAre
sUtro.nme.n to kathAdikakA bhI sambandha milatA bhAsit hotA hai — TUTakapanA bhAsit nahI.n hotA.
tathA anya kaviyo.nse gaNadhar kI buddhi to adhik hogI, unake banAye grantho.nme.n tho.De
shabdo.nme.n bahut artha honA chAhiye; parantu anya kaviyo.n jaisI bhI gambhIratA nahI.n hai.
tathA jo grantha banAye vah apanA nAm aisA nahI.n rakhatA ki — ‘‘amuk kahatA hai,’’
‘‘mai.n kahatA hU.N’’ aisA kahatA hai; parantu tumhAre sUtro.nme.n ‘‘he gautam!’’ va ‘‘gautam kahate hai’’
aise vachan hai.n. parantu aise vachan to tabhI sambhav hai.n jab aur koI kartA ho. isaliye
yah sUtra gaNadharakR^it nahI.n hai.n, aurake banAye gaye hai.n. gaNadhar ke nAmase kalpit-rachanAko pramAN
karAnA chAhate hai.n; parantu vivekI to parIkShA karake mAnate hai.n, kahA hI to nahI.n mAnate.
tathA ve aisA bhI kahate hai ki — gaNadhar sUtro.nke anusAr koI dashapUrvadhArI hue hai.n,
unho.nne yah sUtra banAye hai.n. vahA.N pUChate hai.n — yadi naye grantha banAye hai.n to nayA nAm rakhanA
thA, a.ngAdikake nAm kisaliye rakhe? jaise — koI ba.De shAhUkArakI koThIke nAmase apanA
shAhUkArA pragaT kare — aisA yah kArya huA. sachcheko to jis prakAr digambarame.n grantho.nke aur