346 ] [ pravachan ratnAkar bhAg-9 vichAravAmAn Ave chhe- jo khaDI bhInt-Adi paradravyanI hoy to shun thAy te pratham vichArIe ‘jenun je hoy te te ja hoy, jem AtmAnun gnAn hovAthI gnAn te AtmA ja chhe (-judun dravya nathI);’ -Avo tAttvik sambandh jIvant (arthAt vidyamAn) hovAthI, khaDI jo bhInt-AdinI hoy to khaDI te bhInt-Adi ja hoy (arthAt khaDI bhInt- AdisvarUp ja hovI joIe, bhInt-AdithI judun dravya na hovun joIe); em hotAn, khaDInA svadravyano uchchhed (nAsh) thAy. parantu dravyano uchchhed to thato nathI, kAraN ke ek dravyanun anya dravyarUpe sankramaN thavAno to pUrve ja niShedh karyo chhe. mATe (e siddha thayun ke) khaDI bhInt-AdinI nathI. (AgaL vichArIe) jo khaDI bhInt-AdinI nathI, to khaDI konI chhe? khaDInI ja khaDI chhe. (A) khaDIthI judI evI bIjI kaI khaDI chhe ke jenI (A) khaDI chhe? (A) khaDIthI judI anya koI khaDI nathI, parantu teo be sva- svAmIrUp ansho ja chhe. ahIn sva-svAmIrUp anshonA vyavahArathI shun sAdhya chhe? kAI sAdhya nathI. to pachhI khaDI koInI nathI, khaDI khaDI ja chhe-e nishchay chhe. (e pramANe draShTAnt kahyun.) jem A draShTAnt chhe, tem A (nIche pramANe) drArShTAnt chhe- A jagatamAn chetayitA (chetanAro arthAt AtmA) chhe te gnAnaguNathI bharelA svabhAvavALun dravya chhe. pudgalAdi paradravya vyavahAre te chetayitAnun (AtmAnun) gney chhe, have, ‘gnAyak (arthAt jANanAro) chetayitA, gney (arthAt jaNAvAyogya) je pudgalAdi paradravya teno chhe ke nathI?’ -em te banneno tAttvik sambandh ahIn vichAravAmAn Ave chhe- jo chetayitA pudgalAdino hoy to shun thAy te pratham vichArIe ‘jenun je hoy te te ja hoy, jem AtmAnun gnAn hovAthI gnAn te AtmA ja chhe;’ -Avo tAttvik sambandh jIvant (arthAt chhato) hovAthI, chetayitA jo pudgalAdino hoy to chetayitA te pudgalAdi ja hoy (arthAt chetayitA pudgalAdisvarUp ja hovo joIe, pudgalAdithI judun dravya na hovun joIe); em hotAn, chetayitAnA svadravyano uchchhed thAy. parantu dravyano uchchhed to thato nathI, kAraN ke ek dravyanun anya dravyarUpe sankramaN thavAno to pUrve ja niShedh karyo chhe. mATe (e siddha thayun ke) chetayitA pudgalAdino nathI. (AgaL vichArIe) jo chetayitA pudgalAdino nathI to chetayitA kono chhe? chetayitAno ja chetayitA chhe. (A) chetayitAthI judo evo bIjo kyo chetayitA chhe ke jeno (A) chetayitA chhe? (A) chetayitAthI judo anya koI chetayitA nathI, parantu teo be sva-svAmIrUp ansho ja chhe. ahIn sva-svAmIrUp anshonA vyavahArathI shun sAdhya chhe? kAI sAdhya nathI. to pachhI gnAyak koIno nathI, gnAyak gnAyak ja chhe-e nishchay chhe.