Page 117 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 141 of 321
single page version
have ‘AkAshamAn jem sarva dravyone avagAh ApavAnI shakti chhe tevI avagAh ApavAnI shakti badhay dravyomAn chhe’ em kahe chhe —
artha — badhay dravyomAn paraspar avagAh ApavAnI shakti chhe em nishchayathI tame jANo. jem bhasma ane jalamAn (paraspar) avagAhanashakti chhe tem jIvanA asankhyAtapradeshone paN jANo.
bhAvArtha — jem pAtramAn jal bharI temAn bhasma nAkhIe to te temAn samAy chhe, vaLI temAn sAkar nAkhIe to te paN samAy chhe, ane temAn sony chompIe to te paN temAn samAy chhe, — em avagAhanashakti samajavI. ahIn koI prashna kare ke — badhay dravyomAn avagAhanashakti chhe to e (avagAhashakti) AkAshano asAdhAraN dharma kevI rIte Tharyo? tenun samAdhAn — joke parapar avagAh to badhay dravyo Ape chhe tathapi AkAshadravya sarvathI moTun chhe, tethI temAn badhay dravyo samAy chhe e ja tenI asAdhAraNatA chhe.
artha — jo sarva dravyone svabhAvabhUt avagAhanashakti na hoy to ek ek AkAshanA pradeshamAn sarva dravya kevI rIte varte?
bhAvArtha — ek AkAshapradeshamAn pudgalanAn anant paramANu dravyo, ek jIvano pradesh, ek dharmadravyano pradesh, ek adharmadravyano
Page 118 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 142 of 321
single page version
pradesh ane ek kAlANudravya e pramANe sarva rahe chhe. have e AkAshano pradesh ek pudgalaparamANu barAbar chhe. jo avagAhanashakti na hoy to (e pramANe) shI rIte rahe?
have kALadravyanun svarUp kahe chhe —
artha — je sarva dravyone pariNAm kare chhe te kALadravya chhe ane te ek ek AkAshanA pradeshamAn ek ek kAlANudravya varte chhe.
bhAvArtha — sarva dravyone pratisamay paryAy Upaje chhe ane viNase chhe; evA pariNamanane nimittamAtra kALadravya chhe. lokAkAshanA ek ek pradeshamAn ek ek kALANu rahe chhe ane te nishchayakAL chhe.
have kahe chhe ke — pariNamavAnI svabhAvabhUt shakti to sarva dravyomAn chhe, tyAn anya dravya nimittamAtra chhe —
artha — sarva dravyo potapotAnA pariNAmonAn upAdAnakAraN chhe ane anya bAhya dravya chhe, te anyane nimittamAtra jANo.
bhAvArtha — jem ghaT adinun mATI upAdAnakAraN chhe ane chAk-danDadi nimittakAraN chhe, tem sarva dravyo potapotAnA pariNAmanAn upAdAnakAraN chhe ane kALadravya nimittakAraN chhe.
Page 119 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 143 of 321
single page version
have kahe chhe ke — badhAn dravyone je paraspar upakAr chhe te sahakArIkAraNabhAvathI chhe —
artha — badhay dravyone je paraspar upakAr chhe te sahakArIbhAvathI kAraNabhAv thAy chhe ane te pragaT chhe.
have dravyomAn svabhAvabhUt nAnA (prakAranI) shakti chhe tene koN niShedhI shake chhe? te kahe chhe —
artha — nAnA shaktiyukta badhAy padArtho kALadi labdhi sahit thatAn svayam pariName chhe. temane tem pariNamatAn koI aTakAvavA samartha nathI.
bhAvArtha — sarva dravyo, potapotAnA pariNAmarUp dravya-kShetra-kAL sAmagrIne pAmI pote ja bhAvarUp pariName chhe; temane koI aTakAvI shakatun nathI.
have vyavahArakALanun nirUpaN kare chhe –
Page 120 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 144 of 321
single page version
chhe te atIt (bhUtakALanA) thayA, anAgat arthAt AgAmI thashe tathA vartamAn chhe; e pramANe vyavahArakAL hoy chhe.
bhAvArtha — jIv-pudgalanA je sthUL-sUkShma paryAy bhUtakALanA thaI gayA temane atIt nAmathI kahyA, bhaviShyakALanA thashe temane anAgat nAmathI kahyA tathA je varte chhe temane vartamAn nAmathI kahyA. temane jeTalI vAr lAge chhe tene ja vyavahArakAL nAmathI kahIe chhIe. have jaghanyapaNe to paryAyanI sthiti ek samay mAtra chhe ane madhyam -utkRuShTanA anek prakAr chhe. tyAn AkAshanA ek pradeshathI bIjA pradesh sudhI pudgalano paramANu mand gatie jAy teTalA kALane ek samay kahe chhe. e pramANe jaghanyayuktA sankhyAtasamayane ek AvalI kahe chhe, sankhyAt AvalInA samUhane ek ushvAs kahe chhe, sAt ushvAsano ek stok kahe chhe, sAt stokano ek lav kahe chhe, sADA ADatrIs lavanI ek ghaDI kahe chhe, be ghaDInun ek muhUrta kahe chhe, trIs muhUrtano ek ratri-divas kahe chhe, pandar ratri-divasano ek pakSha kahe chhe, be pakShano ek mAs kahe chhe, be mAsanI ek RUtu kahe chhe, traN RUtunun ek ayan kahe chhe ane be ayananun ek varSha kahe chhe, ityadi palya-sAgar -kalpa adi vyavahArakALanA anek prakAr chhe.
have atIt, anAgat, vartamAn paryAyonI sankhyA kahe chhe —
artha — te dravyonA paryAyomAn atIt paryAy anant chhe, anAgat paryAy temanAthI anantagaNI chhe tathA vartamAn paryAy ek ja chhe.❃ e jeTalA paryAy chhe teTalo ja te vyavahAr kAL chhe. ❃. juo AgaL gAthA 302nI TIkA
Page 121 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 145 of 321
single page version
e pramANe dravyonun nirUpaN karyun. have dravyonA kAraN-kAryabhAvanun nirUpaN kare chhe —
artha — niyamathI pUrvapariNAm sahit dravya chhe te kAraNarUp chhe tathA uttarapariNAm sahit dravya chhe te kAryarUp chhe.
have vastunA traNey kAL viShe kArya-kAraNabhAvano nishchay kare chhe —
artha — pUrve tathA uttar pariNAmane prApta thaIne traNe kALamAn eke ek samayamAn vastunA kAraN-kAryanA visheSh (bhed) hoy chhe.
bhAvArtha — vartamAnasamayamAn je paryAy chhe te pUrvasamay sahit vastunun kArya chhe. e ja pramANe sarva paryAy jANavI. e rIte pratyek samay kArya-kAraNabhAvarUp chhe.
have vastu anantadharma svarUp chhe evo nirNay kare chhe —
Page 122 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 146 of 321
single page version
artha — sarva dravya chhe te traNe kALamAn anantAnant chhe — anant paryAyo sahit chhe; tethI shrI jinendradeve sarva vastune anekAnta arthAt anantadharmasvarUp kahI chhe.
have kahe chhe ke anekAntAtmak vastu ja atharakriyAkArI chhe —
artha — je vastu anekAnta chhe – anekadharmasvarUp chhe te ja niyamathI kArya kare chhe. lokamAn paN bahudharmayukta padArtha chhe te ja kArya karavAvALo dekhAy chhe.
bhAvArtha — lokamAn nitya-anitya, ek-anek ityadi anek dharmayukta vastu chhe te ja kAryakArI dekhAy chhe. jem mATInAn ghaT adi anek kArya bane chhe te jo mATI sarvathA ekarUp-nityarUp vA anekarUp -anityarUp ja hoy to temAn ghaT adi kArya bane nahi. e ja pramANe sarva vastu jANavI.
have sarvathA ekAntarUp vastu kAryakArI nathI em kahe chhe —
artha — vaLI ekAntasvarUp dravya chhe te leshamAtra paN kArya karatun nathI tathA je kArya ja na kare te dravya ja kevun? te to shUnyarUp jevun chhe.
bhAvArtha — je atharakriyArUp hoy tene ja paramArtharUp vastu kahI
Page 123 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 147 of 321
single page version
chhe paN je atharakriyArUp nathI te to AkAshanA phUlanI mAphak shUnyarUp chhe.
have sarvathA nitya-ekAntamAn atharakriyAkArIpaNAno abhAv darshAve chhe —
artha — pariNAm rahit je nitya dravya chhe te kadI viNase-Upaje nahi, to te kArya shI rIte kare? e pramANe je kArya na kare te vastu ja nathI. jo te Upaje – viNase to sarvathA nityapaNun Tharatun nathI.
have kShaNasthAyI (sarvathA anitya – bauddha)ne kAryano abhAv darshAve chhe —
artha — jo kShaNasthAyI – paryAyamAtra tattva kShaN-kShaNamAn anya anya thAy evun vinashvar mAnIe to te anvayI dravyathI rahit thatun thakun kAI paN kArya sAdhatun nathI. kShaNasthAyI-vinashvarane vaLI kArya shAnun? (na ja hoy).
have anekAnta vastumAn ja kAryakAraNabhAv bane chhe em darshAve chhe —
Page 124 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 148 of 321
single page version
artha — traNe kALamAn ek ek samayamAn pUrva-uttar pariNAmano Ashray karI jIvadik vastuomAn navA navA kAyaravisheSh thAy chhe arthAt navA navA paryAy Upaje chhe.
have pUrva-uttarabhAvamAn kAraN-kAryabhAv draDh kare chhe —
artha — pUrvapariNAmayukta dravya chhe te to kAraNabhAvathI varte chhe tathA te ja dravya uttarapariNAmathI yukta thAy tyAre kArya thAy chhe em tame niyamathI jANo.
bhAvArtha — jem pinDarUpe pariNamel mATI to kAraN chhe ane tenun, ghaTarUpe pariNamel mATI te kArya chhe. tem pUrvaparyAy (prathamanA paryAy)nun svarUp kahI have jIv uttaraparyAyayukta thayo tyAre te ja kAryarUp thayo; evo niyam chhe. e pramANe vastunun svarUp kahIe chhIe.
have jIvadravyane paN e ja pramANe anadinidhan kArya-kAraNabhAv sAdhe chhe —
artha — jIvadravya chhe te anadinidhan chhe ane te navA navA
Page 125 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 149 of 321
single page version
paryAyorUpe pragaT pariName chhe; te pratham dravya-kShetra-kAL-bhAvanI sAmagrImAn varte chhe pachhI kAryane – paryAyane prApta thAy chhe.
bhAvArtha — jem koI jIv pahelAn shubhapariNAmarUpe pravarte chhe pachhI svargane prApta thAy chhe, tathA (koI jIv) pahelAn ashubhapariNAm- rUpe pravarte chhe pachhI narakadi paryAyane prApta thAy chhe, em samajavun.
have ‘jIvadravya potAnAn dravya-kShetra-kAL-bhAvamAn rahIne ja navIn paryAyarUp kAryane kare chhe’ em kahe chhe —
artha — jIvadravya chhe te potAnA chetanAsvarUpamAn (bhAvamAn) potAnA ja kShetramAn, potAnA ja dravyamAn tathA potAnA pariNamanarUp samayamAn rahIne ja potAnA paryAyasvarUp kAryane sAdhe chhe.
bhAvArtha — paramArthathI vichArIe to potAnAn ja dravya-kShetra-kAL -bhAvasvarUp thato thako jIv, paryAyasvarUp kAryarUpe pariName chhe ane paradravya-kShetra-kAL-bhAv chhe te to nimittamAtra chhe.
have anyarUp thaIne kArya kare to temAn dUShaN darshAve chhe —
artha — jo jIv potAnA svarUpamAn rahIne paN parasvarUpamAn jAy to paraspar maLavAthI badhay dravyo ekarUp banI jAy; e mahAn
Page 126 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 150 of 321
single page version
doSh Ave. parantu em ekarUp kadI paN thato nathI e pragaT chhe.
have sarvathA ekarUp mAnavAmAn dUShaN darshAve chhe —
artha — jo sarvathA ek ja vastu mAnI badhuy brahmanun svarUp mAnIe to brAhmaN ane chAnDAlano kAI paN bhed raheto nathI.
bhAvArtha — sarva jagatane ek brahmasvarUp mAnIe to nAnAn rUp (bhinna-bhinnarUp) TharatAn nathI. vaLI ‘avidyAthI nAnAn rUp dekhAy chhe’ em mAnIe to e avidyA konAthI utpanna thaI te kaho? jo ‘brahmathI thaI’ em kaho to te brahmathI bhinna chhe ke abhinna chhe? athavA satrUp chhe ke asatrUp chhe? athavA te ekarUp chhe ke anekarUp chhe? e pramANe vichAr karatAn emAnnun kAI Tharatun nathI. mATe vastunun svarUp anekAnta ja siddha thAy chhe ane e ja satyArtha chhe.
have tattvane aNumAtra mAnavAmAn dUShaN darshAve chhe —
artha — jo ek vastu sarvagat-vyApak na mAnavAmAn Ave paN ansharahit, aNuparimAN tattva mAnavAmAn Ave to be anshanA tathA pUrva -uttar anshanA sambandhanA abhAvathI evI aNumAtra vastuthI kAryanI siddhi thatI nathI.
Page 127 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 151 of 321
single page version
bhAvArtha — niransh, kShaNik ane niranvayI vastumAn atharakriyA thAy nahi; mATe vastune kathanchit anshasahit, nitya tathA anvayI mAnavI yogya chhe.
have dravyamAn ekatvapaNAno nishchay kare chhe —
artha — badhay dravyone dravyasvarUpathI to ekatvapaNun chhe tathA potapotAnA guNonA bhedathI sarva dravyo bhinnabhinna chhe.
bhAvArtha — dravyanun lakShaN utpAd-vyay-dhrauvyasvarUp sat chhe. have e svarUpathI to sarvane ekapaNun chhe. tathA chetanatA-achetanatA adi potapotAnA guNathI bhedarUp chhe mATe guNanA bhedathI badhAn dravyo nyArAn nyArAn chhe. vaLI ek dravyane trikALavartI anant paryAy chhe, te badhA paryAyomAn dravyasvarUpathI to ekatA ja chhe; jem chetananA paryAy badhA chetanasvarUp chhe. tathA pratyek paryAy potapotAnA svarUpathI bhinna-bhinna paN chhe, bhinna-bhinnakALavartI chhe tethI bhinna-bhinna paN kahIe chhIe; parantu temane pradeshabhed nathI. tethI ek ja dravyanA anek paryAy hoy chhe temAn virodh nathI.
have dravyane guN-paryAyasvabhAvapaNun darshAve chhe —
artha — artha eTale vastu chhe; te samaye samaye utpAd-vyay
Page 128 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 152 of 321
single page version
-dhrauvyapaNAnA svabhAvarUp chhe; ane tene guN-paryAy pariNAmasvarUp sattva siddhAntamAn kahyun chhe.
bhAvArtha — jIvadi vastu chhe te Upajavun, viNasavun ane sthir rahevun e traNe bhAvamay chhe, ane je vastu guN-paryAy pariNAmasvarUp chhe te ja sat chhe. jem jIvadravyano chetanA guN chhe, tenun svabhAv- vibhAvarUp pariNaman chhe tathA samaye samaye pariName chhe te paryAy chhe. e ja pramANe pudgaladravyanA sparsha, ras, gandh, varNa guN chhe; te samaye samaye svabhAv ke vibhAvarUpe pariName chhe te paryAy chhe. e pramANe badhAn dravyo guN-paryAy pariNAmasvarUp pragaT chhe.
have dravyonA utpAd-vyay te shun chhe? te kahe chhe —
artha — vastuno pariNAm samaye samaye prathamano to viNase chhe ane anya Upaje chhe; tyAn pahelA pariNAmarUp vastuno to nAsh-vyay chhe tathA anya bIjo pariNAm upajyo tene utpAd kahIe chhIe. e pramANe utpAd-vyay thAy chhe.
have dravyanA dhruvapaNAno nishchay kahe chhe —
artha — jIvadravya, dravyasvarUpathI to nathI nAshane prApta thatun ke nathI Upajatun; tethI dravyamAtrathI jIvane nityapaNun samajavun.
Page 129 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 153 of 321
single page version
bhAvArtha — e ja dhruvapaNun chhe ke jIv, sattA ane chetanAthI to Upajato-viNasato nathI arthAt jIv, koI navo Upajato ke viNasato nathI.
have dravyaparyAyanun svarUp kahe chhe —
artha — jIvadi vastu anvayarUp (sAmAnyarUp) thI dravya chhe ane te ja visheSharUpathI paryAy chhe. vaLI visheSharUpathI dravya paN nirantar Upaje-viNase chhe.
bhAvArtha — anvayarUp paryAyomAn sAmAnyabhAvane dravya kahe chhe tathA visheShabhAv chhe te paryAy chhe. tethI visheSharUpathI dravyane paN utpAd- vyayasvarUp kahe chhe. parantu em nathI ke paryAy, dravyathI judo ja Upaje – viNase chhe. abhedavivakShAthI dravya ja Upaje-viNase chhe tathA bhedavivakShAthI (dravya ane paryAyane) judA paN kahIe chhIe.
have guNanun svarUp kahe chhe —
artha — dravyano je pariNAm (bhAv) sadrash arthAt pUrva-uttar badhIy paryAyomAn samAn hoy-anadinidhan hoy te ja guN chhe. ane te sAmAnyasvarUpathI Upajato-viNasato nathI.
Page 130 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 154 of 321
single page version
bhAvArtha — jem jIvadravyano chetanaguN tenI sarva paryAyomAn mojud chhe – anadinidhan chhe, te sAmAnyasvarUpathI Upajato – viNasato nathI paN visheSharUpathI paryAyamAn vyaktarUp (pragaTarUp) thAy ja chhe, evo guN chhe. tevI rIte badhay dravyomAn pot-potAnA sAdhAraN (sAmAnya) tathA asAdhAraN (visheSh) guNo samajavA.
have kahe chhe ke dravya, guN ane paryAyanun ekapaNun chhe te ja paramArthe vastu chhe —
artha — sarva dravyomAn je guN chhe te paN visheSharUpathI Upaje – viNashe chhe. e pramANe dravya-guN-paryAyonun ekapaNun chhe ane te ja paramArthabhUt vastu chhe.
bhAvArtha — guNanun svarUp evun nathI ke je vastuthI sarvathA bhinna ja hoy. guN-guNIne kathanchit abhedapaNun chhe tethI je paryAy Upaje – viNase chhe te guN – guNIno vikAr chhe (visheSh AkAr chhe). eTalA mATe guNane paN UpajatA – viNasatA kahIe chhIe. evun ja nityanityAtmak vastunun svarUp chhe. e pramANe dravya-guN-paryAyonI ekatA e ja paramArthabhUt vastu chhe.
have AshankA thAy chhe ke — dravyomAn paryAy vidyamAn Upaje chhe ke avidyamAn Upaje chhe? evI AshankAnun samAdhAn kare chhe –
Page 131 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 155 of 321
single page version
artha — jo ‘dravyamAn paryAyo chhe te paN vidyamAn chhe ane tirohit eTale DhankAyelA chhe’ em mAnIe to utpatti kahevI ja viphal (vyartha) chhe. jem devadatta kapaDAthI DhankAyelo hato tene ughADyo eTale kahe ke ‘A Upajyo’, paN em Upajavun kahevun te vAstavik nathI – vyartha chhe; tem dravyamAn paryAy DhAnkI – UghaDIne UpajatI kahevI te paramArtha nathI. mATe dravyamAn avidyamAn paryAyanI ja utpatti kahIe chhIe.
artha — anadinidhan dravyamAn kALadi labdhithI sarva paryAyonI avidyamAn ja utpatti chhe.
bhAvArtha — anadinidhan dravyamAn kALadi labdhithI avidyamAn arthAt aNachhatI paryAy ja Upaje chhe. paN em nathI ke ‘badhI paryAyo ek ja samayamAn vidyamAn chhe te DhankAtI – UghaDatI jAy chhe.’ parantu samaye samaye kramapUrvak navIn navIn ja paryAyo Upaje chhe. dravya to trikALavartI sarva paryAyono samudAy chhe ane kALabhedathI paryAyo krame thAy chhe.
have dravya ane paryAyone kathanchit bhed-abhedapaNun darshAve chhe —
artha — dravya ane paryAyamAn dharma-dharmInI vivakShAthI bhed karavAmAn Ave chhe; parantu vastusvarUpathI bhed thaI shakato nathI.
bhAvArtha — dravya ane paryAyamAn dharma-dharmInI vivakShAthI bhed
Page 132 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 156 of 321
single page version
karavAmAn Ave chhe arthAt dravya dharmI chhe ane paryAy dharma chhe. vastupaNe e banne abhed ja chhe. koI naiyayikadik dharma-dharmImAn sarvathA bhed mAne chhe; temano mat pramANabadhit chhe.
have dravya ane paryAyamAn sarvathA bhed mAne chhe temanA matamAn dUShaN darshAve chhe —
यदि वस्तुतः विभेदः पर्यायद्रव्ययोः मन्यसे मूढ ।
ततः निरपेक्षा सिद्धिः द्वयोः अपि च प्राप्नोति नियमात् ।।२४६।।
artha — dravya ane paryAyamAn (sarvathA) bhed mAne chhe tene kahe chhe ke – he mUDh! jo tun dravya ane paryAyamAn vastupaNAthI paN bhed mAne chhe to dravya ane paryAy bannenI nirapekSha siddhi niyamathI prApta thAy chhe.
bhAvArtha — (em mAnatAn) dravya ane paryAy judI judI vastu Thare chhe paN temAn dharma-dharmIpaNun Tharatun nathI.
have jeo vignAnane ja advait kahe chhe ane bAhya padArtha mAnatA nathI. temanA matamAn dUShaN darshAve chhe —
artha — jo badhIy vastu ek gnAn ja chhe ane te ja nAnArUpathI sthit chhe – rahe chhe to em mAnatAn gney kAI paN na Tharyun, ane gney vinA gnAn ja kevI rIte Tharashe?
bhAvArtha — vignAnAdvaitavAdI – bauddhamatI kahe chhe ke — ‘gnAnamAtra ja
Page 133 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 157 of 321
single page version
tattva chhe ane te ja nAnArUpathI birAje chhe.’ tene kahe chhe ke – jo gnAnamAtra chhe to gney kAI paN na rahyun ane gney nathI to gnAn kevI rIte kaho chho? kAraN ke gneyane jANe te ja gnAn kahevAy chhe paN gney vinA gnAn nathI.
artha — ghaT, paT adi samasta jaD dravyo gneyasvarUpathI bhalA prakAre prasiddha chhe ane temane gnAn jANe chhe tethI teo AtmAthI – gnAnathI bhinnarUp judAn Thare chhe.
bhAvArtha — jaDadravya evA gneyapadArtho AtmAthI bhinnarUp judA judA prasiddha chhe teno lop shI rIte karI shakAy? jo tene na mAnavAmAn Ave to gnAn paN na Thare, kAraN ke jANyA vinA gnAn shAnun?
artha — deh-makAn adi bAhya padArtho sarvalokaprasiddha chhe, temane paN jo gnAn ja mAnasho, to te vAdI gnAnanun nAm paN jANato nathI.
bhAvArtha — bAhya padArthane paN gnAn ja mAnavAvALo gnAnanun svarUp ja jANato nathI e to dUr raho, paN gnAnanun nAm paN jANato nathI.
have nastikavAdI pratye kahe chhe —
Page 134 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 158 of 321
single page version
artha — je nastikavAdI jIv-ajIvadi ghaNA prakAranA padArthone Ankho vaDe pratyakSha dekhato hovA chhatAn paN kahe chhe ke – ‘kAI paN nathI’ te asatyavAdIomAn paN mahA asatyavAdI chhe.
bhAvArtha — pratyakSha dekhAtI vastune paN ‘nathI’ em kahenAro mahA jUTho chho.
artha — sarva vastu satrUp chhe – vidyamAn chhe, te vastu asatrUp – avidyamAn kem thAy? athavA ‘kAI paN nathI’ evun to shUnya chhe, em paN kevI rIte jANe?
bhAvArtha — chhatI (vidyamAn – pragaT – mojUd) vastu achhatI (avidyamAn) kem thAy? tathA ‘kAI paN nathI’ to evun kahevAvALo – jANavAvALo paN na rahyo, pachhI ‘shUnya chhe’ em koNe jANyun?
have A ja gAthA pAThAntararUpe A pramANe chhe —
artha — jo badhIy vastu asat chhe to (asat chhe) em kahevAvALo nastikavAdI paN asatrUp Tharyo, to pachhI ‘koI paN tattva
Page 135 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 159 of 321
single page version
nathI.’ em te kevI rIte kahe chhe? athavA ‘kahevAvALo paN nathI,’ to shUnya chhe em shI rIte jANe chhe?
bhAvArtha — pote pragaT vidyamAn chhe ane kahe chhe ke ‘kAI paN nathI’ paN em kahevun e moTun agnAn chhe; tathA shUnyatattva kahevun e to mAtra pralAp (phogaT bakavAd) ja chhe, kAraN ke kahevAvALo ja nathI to A kahe chhe koN? tethI nastitvavAdI mAtra pralApI (mithyA bakavAdI) chhe.
artha — ghaNun kahevAthI shun? jeTalAn nAm chhe teTalA ja niyamathI padArtho paramArtharUpe chhe.
bhAvArtha — jeTalAn nAm chhe teTalA satyArtharUp padArtho chhe. ghaNun kahevAthI bas thAo! e pramANe padArthonun svarUp kahyun.
have, e padArthone jANavAvALun gnAn chhe tenun svarUp kahe chhe —
artha — je nAnA dharmo sahit AtmAne tathA paradravyone potAnI yogyatAnusAr jANe chhe tene siddhAntamAn nishchayathI gnAn kahe chhe.
bhAvArtha — potAnA AvaraNanA kShayopasham ke kShay anusAr jANavAyogya padArtha je pote tathA par, tene je jANe chhe te gnAn chhe. e sAmAnyagnAnanun svarUp kahyun.
Page 136 of 297
PDF/HTML Page 160 of 321
single page version
have sarvapratyakSha evA kevaLagnAnanun svarUp kahe chhe —
artha — je gnAn, dravya-paryAyasahit sarva lok tathA sarva alokane prakAshe chhe — jANe chhe te sarvapratyakSha kevaLagnAn chhe.
have gnAnane sarvagat kahe chhe —
artha — gnAn sarva lok-alokane jANe chhe tethI gnAnane sarvagat paN kahIe chhIe, vaLI gnAn chhe te jIvane chhoDI anya gney padArthomAn jatun nathI.
bhAvArtha — gnAn sarva lokAlokane jANe chhe tethI tene sarvagat vA sarvavyApak kahIe chhIe. parantu te jIvadravyano guN chhe mATe jIvane chhoDI anya padArthomAn jatun nathI.
have ‘gnAn jIvanA pradeshomAn rahIne ja sarvane jANe chhe’ em kahe chhe —