42
mumukShuH- dhruv binA akele utpAd-vyayakA vichAr karanA bhI vyartha hai.
samAdhAnaH- vyartha hai. dhruv binA akelA utpAd-vyay kyA? kahI.n asatakA utpAd nahI.n hotA. jo nahI.n hai, usakA vyay nahI.n hotA, jo hai usakA vyay hotA hai. dhruvatA TikAkar utpAd aur vyay hote hai.n. paryAyakA utpAd-vyay hai aur dravya svaya.n TikatA hai.
mumukShuH- vastukA ba.ndhAraN pahale jAnanA chAhiye. to vah ba.ndhAraN kaisA? vastukA ba.ndhAraN kise kahate hai.n?
samAdhAnaH- vastu kis svabhAv-se hai? vah kis prakAr-se nitya hai? kis prakAr-se anitya hai? kis apekShA-se nitya hai? kis apekShA-se anitya? usakA utpAd-vyay kyA? usakA dhruv kyA? usakA dravya kyA? use guN kyA? usakI paryAy kyA? dravya kaisA svataHsiddha anAdiananta hai? vah sab usakA ba.ndhAraN hai. dravya-guN- paryAy, utpAd-vyay aur svataHsiddhapanA anAdiananta, Adi sab usakA ba.ndhAraN hai. phir dravya, usame.n vibhAv kaise huA? usakA svabhAv kaise pragaT ho? mUl vastu, usake dravya-guN-paryAy, utpAd-vyay usakA-dravyakA ba.ndhAraN hai. usakA koI kartA nahI.n hai, svaya.n svataHsiddha vastu hai. vah usakA ba.ndhAraN hai.
mumukShuH- koI paryAy shuddha ho yA ashuddha ho, vah dhruvame.n-se to nikalatI nahI.n hai. nikale to dhruv khAlI ho jAya. to phir svabhAv par dR^iShTi jAy to hI paryAyame.n shuddha a.nsh pragaT ho, usakA kyA kAraN?
samAdhAnaH- dhruvame.n-se nahI.n nikalatI hai arthAt jo vastu svaya.n ananta shakti- ananta guN-se bharI vastu hai. dR^iShTi svabhAv par jAy, usame.n guN pAriNAmikabhAv hai, usame.n paryAy pragaT hotI hai. dhruv khAlI nahI.n ho jAtA. ananta kAl pariName to bhI dravya kahI.n khAlI nahI.n ho jAtA. pariName to bhI jyo.nkA tyo.n rahatA hai. aisI dravyakI koI achi.ntyatA hai. usame.n ananta guN hai.n. un guNo.nkI paryAy-usakA kArya hotA hI rahatA hai. yadi kArya na ho to vah guN kaisA? vah aisA kUTastha nahI.n hai. to phir dravya pahachAname.n hI na Aye. dravya akelA kUTastha ho aur pariName hI nahI.n, to vah dravya pahachAname.n nahI.n AtA ki yah chetan hai yA jaD hai. dravya yadi pariName nahI.n to pahachAn hI nahI.n ho. akelA kUTastha ho to.
kUTastha to (isaliye kahate hai.n ki) tU paryAy par yA bhed par dR^iShTi na kara. dR^iShTi ek akhaNDa jo ekarUp vastu hai us par dR^iShTi kara. dravyakA jo pAriNAmik svabhAv hai usakA nAsh nahI.n hotA. dravyakI dravyatA kahI.n chalI nahI.n jAtI. dravya pariNamatA hai. us par dR^iShTi kare to dravya jis svabhAvarUp ho us svabhAvarUp pariNamatA hai. usakI dR^iShTi vibhAv taraph hai to vibhAvakI paryAy hotI hai aur svabhAv par dR^iShTi jAy to