mAne chhe. vaLI AtmA be prakAranA kahe chhe, paN tenun nirUpaN pahelAn karyun chhe. man koI judo
padArtha nathI. bhAvaman to gnAnarUp chhe ane te AtmAnun svarUp chhe, tathA dravyaman paramANuono
pinD chhe ane te sharIranun ang chhe. e pramANe e dravyo kalpit jANavAn.
dveSh, snigdha, gurutva ane dravyatva. have temAn sparshAdik guN to paramANuomAn hoy chhe, parantu
pRithvIne gandhavatI ja kahevI, tathA jaLane shItasparshavAn kahevun, ityAdi mithyA chhe. kAraN ke
ke
chhe, kAI vastumAn to nathI, paN anya padArthanI apekShAe anya padArthanA hInAdhikapaNAne jANavA
mATe potAnA gnAnamAn sankhyAdikanI kalpanAvaDe vichAr karIe chhIe. vaLI buddhi Adi chhe te
AtmAnun pariNaman chhe. tyAn ‘buddhi nAm to gnAnanun chhe. ane te AtmAno ja guN chhe, tathA
‘man’ nAm chhe, paN tene to dravyomAn kahyun ja hatun, to ahIn tene guN shA mATe kahyo? vaLI
sukhAdik chhe, te AtmAmAn kadAchit ja hoy chhe, tethI e guN AtmAnA lakShaNabhUt to nathI,
paN avyAptapaNAthI lakShaNAbhAs chhe. snigdhAdi to pudgalaparamANumAn hoy chhe, ane snigdha,
gurutva ityAdi to sparshanaindriyavaDe jANIe chhIe, tethI sparshanaguNamAn garbhit thayA, judAn shA
mATe kaho chho? vaLI dravyatvaguN jaLamAn kahyA, paN em to agni AdimAn paN Urdhvagamanatva
Adi hoy chhe, to kAn to e badhA kahevA hatA, agar to sAmAnyamAn garbhit kahevA hatA?
e pramANe e guNo kahyA te paN kalpit chhe.
hotI nathI, cheShTA to ghaNA ja prakAranI thAy chhe. vaLI emane judI tattvasangnA kahI, paN kAn
to judA padArtha hoy to tene judAn tattva kahevAn hatAn, agar kAn to kAm
hoy to pAShANAdikanI paN anek avasthAo thAy chhe, to tene paN kahyA karo, paN tethI kAI
sAdhya nathI.