chhe te nitya chhe ke kShaNik? jo nitya chhe, to sarva kShaNik shAthI kahe chhe? tathA jo kShaNik chhe,
to jeno AdhAr ja kShaNik chhe, te sanskAronI paramparA kevI rIte kahe chhe? vaLI sarva kShaNik
thayun tyAre pote paN kShaNik thayo, to tun evI vAsanAne mArga kahe chhe, paN e mArganA phaLane
pote to pAmato ja nathI, to pachhI e mArgamAn shA mATe pravarte chhe? vaLI tArA matamAn nirarthak
shAstra shA mATe karyAn? kAraN ke – upadesh to kAI kartavyavaDe phaL pAmavA mATe ApIe chhIe.
e pramANe A mArga paN mithyA chhe.
vaLI rAgAdik gnAnasantAnavAsanAno uchchhed arthAt nirodh, tene mokSha kahe chhe. paN kShaNik
thayo tyAre mokSha kone kahe chhe? rAgAdikano abhAv thavo ame paN mAnIe chhIe, paN potAnA
gnAnAdik svarUpano abhAv thatAn to potAno abhAv thAy, to teno upAy karavo hitakArI kem
hoy? hitAhitano vichAr karavAvALun to gnAn ja chhe, to potAnA abhAvane gnAnI hit kem
mAne?
bauddhamatamAn pratyakSha ane anumAn e be ja pramAN mAne chhe. paN tenA satyAsatyanun
nirUpaN jainashAstrothI jANavun. jo e be ja pramAN chhe, to temanA shAstra apramAN thayAn to
tenun nirUpaN shA mATe karyun? kAraN ke – pratyakSha anumAn to jIv pote ja karI leshe, tame shAstra
shA mATe banAvyAn?
vaLI teo sugatane dev mAne chhe, ane tenun nagna vA vikriyArUp svarUp sthApe chhe, je
viTambaNArUp chhe. kamanDaL ane raktAmbaranA dhArak, pUrvAhnakALamAn bhojan karanAr, ityAdi lingarUp
bauddhamatanA bhikShuk hoy chhe, paN kShaNikane veSh dhAravAnun prayojan shun? parantu mahantatA mATe kalpit
nirUpaN karavun vA veSh dhAravun thAy chhe.
e pramANe bauddha chhe, tenA chAr prakAr chhe – vaibhAShik, sautrAntik, yogAchAr ane
mAdhyamik. temAn vaibhAShik — gnAnasahit padArtha mAne chhe, sautrAntik — pratyakSha dekhAy chhe te ja
chhe, e sivAy kaI nathI, em mAne chhe, yogAchAr — AchArasahit buddhine mAne chhe, tathA
mAdhyam — padArthanA Ashray vinA gnAnane ja mAne chhe. teo mAtra potapotAnI kalpanA kare chhe,
paN vichAr karatAn temAn kAI ThekANAnI vAt nathI.
e pramANe bauddhamatanun nirUpaN karyun.
✾ chArvAkamat – nirAkaraN ✾
‘‘koI sarvagnadev, dharma, adharma, mokSha, paralok ane pAp – puNyanun phaL chhe ja nahi. A
indriyagochar je kaI chhe te ja lok chhe’’ — em chArvAk kahe chhe.
tene pUchhIe chhIe ke — sarvagnadev A kAL – kShetramAn nathI ke sarvakAL – kShetramAn nathI? A
134 ][ mokShamArgaprakAshak