jo AtmA vyApak hoy to tenI pratIti kevaL sharIramAn ja kem thAy? bIje paN thavI joItI
hatI. parantu sharIr sivAy bIje kyAy paN tenI prApti thatI nathI. tethI nishchit chhe ke AtmA
sharIr pramAN ja chhe, nahi ke sarvavyApak. ‘AtmA pAnch bhUtothI utpanna thayo chhe’ A chArvAk
matane dUShit batAvatAn ahIn em kahyun chhe ke AtmA svabhAvathI ja gnAtA draShTA chhe tethI te
bhUtajanit nathI. jo em hoy to AtmAmAn svabhAvathI chaitanyaguN prApta thavo joIto na hato.
enun paN kAraN e chhe ke kArya prAya potAnA upAdAn kAraN anusAr ja utpanna thAy chhe,
jem mATImAnthI utpanna thanAr ghaDAmAn mATInA ja guN (mUrtikapaNun ane achetanapaNun Adi)
prApta thAy chhe. tevI ja rIte jo AtmA panchabhUtathI utpanna thayo hot to temAn bhUtanA guN
achetanapaNun Adi ja prApta thavA joItA hatA, nahi ke svAbhAvik chetanatva Adi. parantu temAn
achetanapaNAnI viruddha chetanapaNun ja prApta thAy chhe, mATe siddha chhe ke te AtmA pRithvI Adi
bhUtothI utpanna thayo nathI. AtmAne sarvathA nitya athavA kShaNik mAnatAn temAn ghaTanI jaLadhAraN
Adi arthakriyAnI jem kAI paN arthakriyA na thaI shake. jem - jo AtmAne kUTastha nitya (traNe
parispandanarUp) thaI shake nahi. evI avasthAmAn kAryanI utpatti pahelAn kAraNano abhAv kevI
rIte kahI shakAshe? kAraN ke jyAn AtmAmAn kadI koI prakArano vikAr sambhavit ja nathI tyAn
te AtmA jevo bhogarUp kArya karatI vakhate hato tevo ja te tenA pahelAn paN hato. to pachhI
shun kAraN chhe ke pahelAn paN bhogarUp kArya na hoy? kAraN hovAthI te hovun ja joItun hatun
ane jo te pahelAn na hoy to pachhI pAchhaLathI paN utpanna na thavun joIe. kem ke bhogarUp
kriyAno kartA AtmA sadA ekarUp ja rahe chhe. nahi to tenI kUTastha nityatAno vighAt avashya
thAy. kAraN ke pahelAn je tenI akartApaNArUp avasthA hatI teno vinAsh thaIne kartApaNArUp
navI avasthAno utpAd thayo chhe. A ja kUTastha nityatAno vighAt chhe. e ja rIte jo AtmAne
sarvathA kShaNik ja mAnavAmAn Ave to paN koI prakAranI arthakriyA thaI shakashe nahi kAraN ke
koI paN kArya karavA mATe smRuti, pratyabhignAn, ane ichchhA Adinun rahevun Avashyak hoy chhe.
te A kShaNik ekAnta pakShamAn sambhav nathI. enun paN kAraN e chhe ke jeNe pahelAn koI padArthane
pratyakSha karI lIdho hoy tene ja pAchhaLathI tenun smaraN thAy chhe ane tyAr pachhI ja tenA ukta
anubhUt padArthanA smaraNapUrvak pharIthI pratyakSha thatAn pratyabhignAn paN thAy chhe. parantu jo AtmA
sarvathA kShaNik ja hoy to je chittakShaNane pratyakSha thayun hatun te to te ja kShaNe naShTa thaI gayun
chhe. evI hAlatamAn tenA smaraN ane pratyabhignAnanI sambhAvanA kevI rIte karI shakAy? tathA
ukta smaraN ane pratyabhignAn vinA koI paN kArya karavun asambhav chhe. A rIte kShaNik