nAnyasyAnupalabhyamAnatvAditi kechit . majjitAvadubhayAtmakatvAdAtmakarmobhayamev jIva kArtsnyata karmaNotiriktatvenAnyasyAnupalabhyamAnatvAditi kechit . arthakriyAsamartha karmasanyog ev jIva karmasanyogAtkhaTvAyA iv aShTakAShThasanyogAdatiriktatvenAnyasyAnupalabhyamAnatvAditi kechit . evamevamprakArA itarepi bahuprakArA paramAtmeti vyapadishanti durmedhasa, kintu na te paramArthavAdibhi paramArthavAdin iti nirdishyante .

kuta — kahate hain ki sAtA-asAtArUpase vyApta samasta tIvramandatvaguNonse bhedarUp honevAlA karmakA anubhav hI jIv hai, kyonki sukhadukhase anya alag koI jIv dikhAI nahIn detA .6. koI kahate hain ki shrIkhaNDakI bhAnti ubhayarUp mile hue AtmA aur karma, donon milakar hI jIv hain, kyonki sampUrNatayA karmonse bhinna alag koI jIv dikhAI nahIn detA .7. koI kahate hain ki arthakriyAmen (prayojanabhUt kriyAmen) samartha aisA jo karmakA sanyog vah hI jIv hai, kyonki jaise ATh lakaDiyonke sanyogase bhinna alag koI palang dikhAI nahIn detA isI prakAr karmonke sanyogase anya alag koI jIv dikhAI nahIn detA . (ATh lakaDiyAn milakar palang banA tab vah arthakriyAmen samartha huA; isIprakAr yahAn bhI jAnanA .) .8. isaprakAr ATh prakAr to yah kahe aur aise aise anya bhI anek prakArake durbuddhi (vividh prakArase) parako AtmA kahate hain; parantu paramArthake gnAtA unhen satyArthavAdI nahIn kahate .

bhAvArtha : — jIv-ajIv donon anAdikAlase ekakShetrAvagAhasanyogarUpase mile hue hain, aur anAdikAlase hI pudgalake sanyogase jIvakI anek vikArasahit avasthAyen ho rahI hain . paramArthadRuShTise dekhane par, jIv to apane chaitanyatva Adi bhAvonko nahIn chhoDatA aur pudgal apane mUrtik jaDatva Adiko nahIn chhoDatA . parantu jo paramArthako nahIn jAnate ve sanyogase hue bhAvonko hI jIv kahate hain; kyonki paramArthase jIvakA svarUp pudgalase bhinna sarvagnako dikhAI detA hai tathA sarvagnakI paramparAke Agamase jAnA jA sakatA hai, isaliye jinake matamen sarvagna nahIn hain ve apanI buddhise anek kalpanAyen karake kahate hain . unamense vedAntI, mImAnsak, sAnkhya, yog, bauddha, naiyAyik, vaisheShik, chArvAk Adi matonke Ashay lekar ATh prakAr to pragaT kahe hain; aur anya bhI apanI-apanI buddhise anek kalpanAyen karake anek prakArase kahate hain so kahAn tak kahA jAye ?.39 se 43..

aisA kahanevAle satyArthavAdI kyon nahIn hain so kahate hain : —

90