88

khaṇḍānvay sahit arthaḥ — ahīn koī matāntararūp thaīne āshaṅkā kare chhe — em kahe chhe ke karmabhed chheḥ koī karma shubh chhe, koī karma ashubh chhe. shā kāraṇathī? hetubhed chhe, svabhāvabhed chhe, anubhavabhed chhe, āshray bhinna chhe; — ā chār bhedonā kāraṇe karmabhed chhe. tyān hetuno arthāt kāraṇano bhed chhe. vivaraṇ — saṅkaleshapariṇāmathī ashubhakarma bandhāy chhe, vishuddhapariṇāmathī shubhabandh thāy chhe. svabhāvabhed arthāt prakr̥itibhed chhe. vivaraṇ — ashubhakarmasambandhī prakr̥iti bhinna chhe — pudgalakarmavargaṇā bhinna chhe; shubhakarmasambandhī prakr̥iti bhinna chhe — pudgalakarmavargaṇā paṇ bhinna chhe. anubhav arthāt karmano ras, teno paṇ bhed chhe. vivaraṇ — ashubhakarmanā udaye jīv nārakī thāy chhe athavā tiryañch thāy chhe athavā hīn manuṣhya thāy chhe, tyān aniṣhṭa viṣhayasanyogarūp duḥkhane pāme chhe; ashubh karmano svād evo chhe. shubh karmanā udaye jīv dev thāy chhe athavā uttam manuṣhya thāy chhe, tyān iṣhṭa viṣhayasanyogarūp sukhane pāme chhe; shubhakarmano svād evo chhe. tethī svādabhed paṇ chhe. āshray arthāt phaḷanī niṣhpatti evo paṇ bhed chhe. vivaraṇ – ashubhakarmanā udaye hīṇo paryāy thāy chhe, tyān adhik saṅkalesh thāy chhe, tenāthī sansāranī paripāṭī thāy chhe; shubhakarmanā udaye uttam paryāy thāy chhe, tyān dharmanī sāmagrī maḷe chhe, te dharmanī sāmagrīthī jīv mokṣha jāy chhe, tethī mokṣhanī paripāṭī shubhakarma chhe. — āvun koī mithyāvādī māne chhe. tenā prati uttar ām chhe ke — ‘‘कर्मभेदः न हि’’ koī karma shubharūp, koī karma ashubharūp — evo bhed to nathī. shā kāraṇathī? ‘‘हेतुस्वभावानुभवाश्रयाणां सदा अपि अभेदात्’’ (हेतु) karmabandhanān kāraṇ vishuddhapariṇām-saṅkaleshapariṇām evā banne pariṇām ashuddharūp chhe, agnānarūp chhe; tethī kāraṇabhed paṇ nathī, kāraṇ ek ja chhe. (स्वभाव) shubhakarma-ashubhakarma evān banne karma pudgalapiṇḍarūp chhe, tethī ek ja svabhāv chhe, svabhāvabhed to nathī. (अनुभव) ras te paṇ ek ja chhe, rasabhed to nathī. vivaraṇ — shubhakarmanā udaye jīv bandhāyo chhe, sukhī chhe; ashubhakarmanā udaye jīv bandhāyo chhe, duḥkhī chhe; visheṣh to kāī nathī. (आश्रय) phaḷanī niṣhpatti, te paṇ ek ja chhe, visheṣh to kāī nathī. vivaraṇ — shubhakarmanā udaye sansār, tevī ja rīte ashubhakarmanā udaye sansār; visheṣh to kāī nathī. āthī evo artha nishchit thayo ke koī karma bhalun,